News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by moistly on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @10:07PM (#30173176)
And now the truckers blocking the Coutts border crossing — preventing incoming truckers from doing their job and creating the very supply chain crisis they were warning us about! — have taken a run at the RCMP that were breaking up the blockade.

“[Alberta Premier] Kenney calls for calm at border blockade, citing attempted ramming of RCMP members”

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/coutts-border-blockad...

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by ipaddr on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:45AM (#30174564)
The author's point is one day the protests you care about will be judged in the same manner. Unfairly.
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by UncleMeat on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @08:53AM (#30177486)
One day?

Leftist protests have been judged in this manner for a century. I see zero evidence that saying "oh, well, it was just a couple of nazi flags" will cause people to ignore anarchists who show up at leftist marches and burn cars.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by notafraudster on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @07:30AM (#30176611)
I think there are strong incentives for people to disagree with a protest to characterize it as more radical than it is. Likewise, there are strong incentives for moderates inside a protest to disavow radicals and forcefully defend the protest's reputation. Finally, there are strong incentives for radicals inside the protest to minimize or lie about their own radicalism.

Doesn't the argument go "more speech, not less"? I'm really not troubled by the idea that different groups in society contest the meaning of collective action. 2020's George Floyd protests were widely decried in some circles, praised in others, praised with an asterisk in others still, and that's basically part of how society engages in collective meaning-making, so what's the problem?

My guess is that the end consensus on this protest will be more or less exactly what it appears to be: a bunch of hayseed idiots, many of whom have fringe (even if not racist) views, briefly annoyed the fuck out of regular Bytowners in a quixotic and futile effort to achieve a set of unclear but mostly odious goals; a handful of them will end up choking to death in a hospital 6 weeks from now; and Canada isn't going to drop a widely supported rule that also makes no sense to drop (because the U.S. hasn't dropped their side, so unilateral changes won't actually benefit anyone).

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by pjc50 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @04:35AM (#30175498)
.. that already happens though?
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by Sparyjerry on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @09:15PM (#30172706)
There are actually videos of people at the trucker protest shouting out those people, from their area at least and just because YOU haven't seen that doesn't mean it isn't happening. Those 'swastika' people always seem to be fully masked up, with even full face masks, hiding their identity. Just because they aren't beating them up in the street doesn't mean they aren't against them. You see some protests with some people burning down multiple buildings that are called mostly peaceful protests, and yet you are claiming because there may be 1 or 2 people out of 50,000 carrying a confederate flag that that is now represents the protest. Again, these people are against vaccine mandates and are not vaccine deniers - there is a big difference. Many countries have even removed all forms of vaccine passports and mandates because it has been proven that vaccines do not stop the spread of the virus. Canada is simply behind the curve in recognizing this.
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by 0xy on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:52AM (#30174600)
If it was outsiders causing trouble, it certainly wouldn't be the first time.

Progressives have staged false flag campaigns concerning racism before, as recently as November. Democratic political operatives dressed up as Charlottesville tiki torch racists and then used connections to try to pin it on the opposition, until they were caught. [1]

[1] https://theintercept.com/2021/11/03/lincoln-project-charlott...

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by Daishiman on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @11:18AM (#30179619)
The article states that it was a failed stunt. On the contrary, the flags in these protests don't seem like much of a stunt at all, considering that far-right associations to anti-vax movements is a well-known.
[dead]
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by Daishiman on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:25PM (#30181679)
> No. It’s a bs talking point the media gleefully pushed to divide the issue into camps and further stoke tensions in the populace. Don’t fall for it.

The only way you can think that is if you yourself live in the bubble of American media where far-right sources have continuously injected skepticism in a way that's unparalleled in any other developed country. In most of the rest of the world this skepticism isn't shared.

At this point the only holdouts are skeptics, who've been wooed by the far-right's ideas of seeding doubt even when there isn't any. A minority of left-wing extremists with various crazy ideas are also vaccine skeptics, but the horseshoe theory of political crazy seems to hold up here.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by SyzygistSix on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @06:56AM (#30176384)
I find it interesting that right wing people found this movement as fertile ground to try to co-opt rather than something like a peace march or a civil rights protest. Or solidarity with the nurses and working class medical staff on the front lines of the pandemic, who probably don't look very kindly at the truckers' attempt to make this an issue about working class people rather than petty selfishness and partisanship.
[dead]
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by s1artibartfast on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:18AM (#30174031)
I think it is fine to disagree with the cause, but the insight was about rhetorical techniques in public thought and their prevalence over time.

I think the point boils down to that people who disagree with the cause should ridicule the cause, and resist the urge build strawmen. Critiques of AnTifa rioters don't don't generalize to BLM protestors. Critiques of AOC aren't the same as critiques of democrats. Critiques of pedophiles are not critiques of privacy advocates.

On some level, people making these generations know them not to be true, but we still repeat them.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by db48x on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:30AM (#30174098)
> Does that mean I'm entitled to have others trust [me]?

Yes, people should trust you. You should trust the people around you. You are entitled to trust merely by existing. This is not a bad thing!

But the article is about the nature of politics in Canada; the protests themselves are actually off–topic. What do you think about the central thesis of the article, that any dissent in a party, protest, or other political movement is now treated as a scandal to be avoided by enforced conformity within the group?

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by Daishiman on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @11:19AM (#30179636)
> Yes, people should trust you. You should trust the people around you. You are entitled to trust merely by existing. This is not a bad thing!

I have seen so many doctored PCR tests and so many antivaxxers lying about their vaccination status that I see no basis to do that on this particular topic.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by aogaili on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:51AM (#30174591)
"the most childish cause for a protest ever."

People losing their jobs, mental health issues on the rise, children not socializing, polarization and division, divergence from other core issues such as the housing crisis, loss of freedom and rights are not childish issues. There are long-term consequences when government locks down an entire country.

Also, I don't understand the long-term strategy here? if 90% of the people are vaccinated and lockdowns are still used widely, then is this the norm now? Are we going to lock down every winter?

Besides, I've lived in Canada for 20 years, every winter season the healthcare system is stretched, if you have flu and want a paper from the doctor to show to your employer you'll need to wait for 5+ hours at your nearest public clinic. Because the healthcare system is free cumbersome many abuse it.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by refurb on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:39AM (#30175209)
So you’re saying that if you don’t see a point to a protest then it’s not valid?
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by AniseAbyss on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:32AM (#30178975)
Thank you. If you are at a protest and someone is waving a Nazi flag? You are the baddie.