News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by devoutsalsa on Monday October 18, 2021 @10:51AM (#28906009)
The ol’ “why should I pay more to insure sick people when I’m healthy?”, followed by the “I’m sick now, can you donate to my GoFundMe treatment find?” routine.
Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by mojzu on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:15AM (#28906265)
The comments that get me are the replies to the insane bills along the lines of "don't worry about it, just spend 10's or 100's of hours on the phone/filling in forms/arguing with insurance reps and maybe, eventually they'll knock the price down by enough not to bankrupt you"

Expecting sick people or their relatives to navigate that kind of bureaucracy to get the care they need and/or avoid dire financial straits just seems insane to me

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by metalliqaz on Monday October 18, 2021 @10:51AM (#28906011)
Lets be honest... we are all sociopaths. Our culture is a sickness.
[dead]
Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by revolvingocelot on Monday October 18, 2021 @10:53AM (#28906038)
There are, uh, several different first-world countries in which health insurance is paid by the government which you could scrutinize to see if your assumption is worth assuming.

Or you could scrutinize the projected numbers, which conclude that it would be less expensive, in terms of government healthcare funding, to eliminate all of the ravenous middlemen causing all of the costs.

Kinda like how it'd be cheaper to just give all the homeless people housing, rather than burn shitloads of social and criminal justice funding to keep them on the streets.

These are ideological positions, though, so good luck changing any of them. So are the rolling presses -- they're not there to prop up a healthcare system, they're there to refill the troughs of irresponsible rich people whose enterprises have become "too big to fail". The problem is that the rich people have come to expect this windfall. Maybe we can save some money for them by cleaning up the healthcare and criminal justice systems!!

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by vidarh on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:32AM (#28906498)
To add something to this to illustrate just how expensive the US healthcare system is:

Because of how hamstrung Medicare and Medicaid are - with laws restricting them from leveraging their size properly in negotiations, Medicare and Medicaid combined cost US taxpayers as much per taxpayer as the NHS costs per UK taxpayer.

The big difference, of course, being that this buys us universal coverage in the UK, while Medicaid and Medicare only covers a portion of the US population. So the cost per recipient of care is many times higher.

Then a whole lot of Americans have to pay again in private insurance to actually get cover.

So for a start, Americans ought to campaign to unshackle Medicare. Remove the regulations preventing it from leveraging its size fully and make it subject to pressure to be cost effective, and put the savings into expanding coverage, and you'd already be a huge step closer to solving the problem.

EDIT: This is an interesting read: https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/explainer/2021... " As proposed in H.R. 3, drug pricing negotiation would reduce federal spending by $456 billion and increase revenues by $45 billion over 10 years." -- this is a plan that still puts lots of restrictions on how hard Medicare can negotiate. Also: https://www.kff.org/medicare/issue-brief/whats-the-latest-on...

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by m_ke on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:06AM (#28906153)
Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by incrudible on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:20AM (#28906331)
You are mistaking list prices with cost. Nobody pays list price. List price is an anchor for price negotiation. This works against you as an uninsured individual, because you have no negotiating power. Insurance companies act as the wholesaler and they insist on locking you into a complicated subscription model. They can only do this because drug purchases are heavily regulated.
Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by revolvingocelot on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:24AM (#28906376)
>List price is an anchor for price negotiation

As someone who hails from a place whose enormous single-bloc healthcare system can dictate the terms you're describing, I don't think that statement is the explanatory gotcha you intend it to be. Those regulations are there for a reason -- to ensure your for-profit healthcare system makes profit. What if the middlemen were gone and it didn't have to?

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by incrudible on Monday October 18, 2021 @01:23PM (#28908020)
Sure, middlemen make profit, but nobody makes that kind of profit. Nobody pays these prices. Drug prices in the US system may be elevated, but in the grand scheme of things it's a modest part of the total cost.

Furthermore, the reason that these prices can be charged is the regulatory moat, courtesy of the government. Suppose that same government would enact a single-payer system, what makes you believe it wouldn't pay outrageous drug prices, courtesy of the taxpayer? The mechanism that gives the pharma lobby free reign won't just disappear over night.

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by revolvingocelot on Monday October 18, 2021 @02:09PM (#28908901)
> Sure, middlemen make profit, but nobody makes that kind of profit. Nobody pays these prices. Drug prices in the US system may be elevated, but in the grand scheme of things it's a modest part of the total cost.

"Aw, it's not so bad!"

>Furthermore, the reason that these prices can be charged is the regulatory moat, courtesy of the government. Suppose that same government would enact a single-payer system, what makes you believe it wouldn't pay outrageous drug prices, courtesy of the taxpayer? The mechanism that gives the pharma lobby free reign won't just disappear over night.

"But also it's super bad, and it's obviously the best we can do."

Don't know what to tell you -- seemed to work everywhere else. I guess that's American exceptionalism for you!

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by incrudible on Monday October 18, 2021 @04:41PM (#28911429)
> "But also it's super bad, and it's obviously the best we can do."

I didn't say that, but it might actually be true. Having the same people that created the current system design a single-payer system or attempt price fixing is unlikely to lead to a better outcome.

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by revolvingocelot on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @09:17AM (#28917736)
Yeah, seemed clear that that was your opinion; that's why I phrased it that way. They say you get the government you deserve!
Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by throw8932894 on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:39AM (#28906609)
Who do you think pays that inflated price? Medicare and government. It is the same as gov backed student loans. It inflates price to sky high prices.

Activists never demand cheaper (or more transparent) health care. They demand state to pay for it!

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by revolvingocelot on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:50AM (#28906791)
>Activists never demand cheaper (or more transparent) health care. They demand state to pay for it!

...it's cheaper that way. That's-- that's why they say that. You can keep repeating yourself, but tell me, what makes almost every other first-world country better at this than the States? How is it that we can pay so much less and have, in aggregate, better health outcomes? It's a mystery!

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by throw8932894 on Monday October 18, 2021 @12:11PM (#28907085)
You are out of reality.

My country has public health insurance, but gov also works hard to keep costs down. If we paid for drugs like this, the public system would bankrupt.

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by revolvingocelot on Monday October 18, 2021 @12:23PM (#28907253)
Perhaps you find this unpleasant, but the reality is that my government is able to dictate terms to pharmacorps such that we do not have to "pay for drugs like this". The whole point is that the exorbitant costs are not the true costs, they're just what you'll get charged unless you stand together.
Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by metalliqaz on Monday October 18, 2021 @10:56AM (#28906064)
not to mention freeing up the costs paid by employers and employees, which would then be freed for commerce.
Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by revolvingocelot on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:00AM (#28906100)
Ahh, but holding that Sword of Damocles over employees' heads is too valuable! Disincentives quitting, or even dissent. Not sure why the owner class would go for that, TBH.
Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by metalliqaz on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:01AM (#28906112)
indeed they lobby against it

but imagine how much easier it would be to start a business if you didn't need to be a wage slave for the man to insure your family

Re:Arthritis drug that cost $198 in 2008 is now more than $10k by amusedcyclist on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:43AM (#28906657)
Basic economic theory and comparative studies will tell you that a single buyer for healthcare gives that single buyer a lot of leverage, which makes it cheaper.