News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Experimental study shows physicians trade optimal patient... by ajscherer on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @12:55PM (#2869099)
So, you knew your troll post would be downvoted, as evidenced by your prediction, and yet you still post it and complain about it when it happens?

It's not just that your post contained no thought other than "Government bad!"... your post had absolutely nothing to do with the article.

From TFA:

"In a controlled setting, the researchers asked medical students to choose the quantity of medical care to provide to hypothetical patients enrolled in either fee-for-service (FFS) or capitated insurance plans"

Capitated and fee-for-service are two methods used by private and public entities to pay for health care. The article was about how doctors behaved (or at least how medical students said they'd behave) under each of those two systems. I don't find the experiment convincing, but I can read well enough to know it had nothing to do with whether the payment was publically or privately funded.

An anti-Obama bumper sticker would be a much more appropriate forum for your opinions than this thread.

Re:Experimental study shows physicians trade optimal patient... by jkeel on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @12:45PM (#2869060)
I didn't downvote but _delirium is correct that you didn't provide any details to an argument. After reading your first sentence I was expecting some examples (maybe the example that health insurance plans can't cross state lines, HIPAA, etc.). The health industry seems to be pretty profitable so I'm not sure what perspective you are coming from when you say "damage".

On a side note, don't set yourself up for a downvote by only providing an opinionated comment and then play the victim card stating that a biased subsection of the community is out to get you.

I should add that I think people should not downvote you just because they don't agree with you, but they should be allowed to downvote you if you are not providing value to the conversation.

[deleted]
Re:Experimental study shows physicians trade optimal patient... by jkeel on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @01:03PM (#2869143)
Yeah, I'm on the fence. Sometimes I see great back and forth conversations and sometimes I see people buried into the ground. I think it's still work laying out where you are coming from and if others downvote you based on disagreement then it's their problem.

As for my comments of "out to get you" or "victim card" I think I should have said, "don't become a self fulfilling prophecy". I don't necessarily think you are playing a victim card. Either way, keep participating. You've at least created quite the discussion thread.

Re:Experimental study shows physicians trade optimal patient... by wisty on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @12:24PM (#2868948)
The US has been great for the industry. They subsidize it more than the UK, which is almost entirely socialized and free.
Re:Experimental study shows physicians trade optimal patient... by arethuza on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @12:30PM (#2868974)
The UK NHS is "free at the point of delivery" - not "free".
[deleted]
Re:Experimental study shows physicians trade optimal patient... by systemtrigger on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @12:39PM (#2869023)
You said "Considering the damage the US government has done to the industry..."
Re:Experimental study shows physicians trade optimal patient... by _delirium on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @12:25PM (#2868953)
I downvoted your post because it didn't really make an argument; same as I'd do if the post was a typically reflexive blaming of "insurance companies" or "greed". I don't think hearing either the left-leaning or right-leaning soundbytes on medicine yet again is useful to anyone.
[deleted]
Re:Experimental study shows physicians trade optimal patient... by CapitalistCartr on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @12:32PM (#2868985)
It isn't, and that's not at all what he said. As he said, your post didn't make an argument. Your first post was inflammatory without substance, and this post is inflammatory combined with a strawman. Yes, on HN that behavior will get you downvoted.
Re:Experimental study shows physicians trade optimal patient... by systemtrigger on Wednesday August 10, 2011 @12:47PM (#2869068)
> I've attempted to 'argue' Austrian style economics here before

Careful what you claim. Your account is brand new and shows no such comment history.