News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by wolverine876 on Monday May 24, 2021 @01:49PM (#27267479)
Could it be that people legitimately disagree with you, without being quislings or whatever? I think what has changed is the deligitimization of differing opinions and the dehumanization of people who hold them. That has become normalized - ok, even encouraged behavior - for a certain political grouping, which is indeed deadly to a democracy, where the foundation is respecting each other's opinions - i.e., we each get an equal vote. If you don't embrace that, then that is what has changed.

Part of freedom is that others are free to do things you don't like and I don't like, including Facebook, Google, and Twitter. The owner of a business can forbid discussion of a topic, such as sports, and kick out or fire anyone who doesn't comply. Heck, they can kick out or fire people for (almost) any reason or without a reason at all. It's their business; they are free.

Free speech is a restriction on the government's actions, not on a business's: Government is limited in restricting speech and similarly it is limited in restricting the behavior of private businesses (though not as limited as when restricting speech).

Private organizations also have good reasons, IMHO, to restrict speech. If you were at a restaurant and insulting people at neighboring tables, the restaurant would be right to kick you out. If you were at a political discussion club and insisted on repeating disinformation, they would be right to kick you out. You would be hurting the experience and value for other members. But private organizations also restrict speech in ways I object to.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by pjkundert on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:54PM (#27268295)
Disagreement is awesome. We need more disagreement, carried out in reliably truth-telling public forums (which do not alter the ratio of up/down votes and related algorithms). If a platform wants to only host legal speech complying with its own views (and filter everything else it deems "bad"), then it's a news paper, not a forum. It has editorial responsibilities (and legal penalties and remedies), if so.

Governments using "private" businesses to distort public debate has a long and horrific history (see every major mass-death totalitarian regime; Mao, Hitler, Stalin, ...). So, I am very worried about all media agreeing in lock-step with government! (eg. All global government, media, education, judicial and medical authorities in total agreement with global mass deployment of experimental medical treatments, for example, and sinking/de-platforming all dissent...)

I will lay down my life to ensure you have the right to publicly display your opinion -- especially if I find it ridiculous, or even repulsive. Unfortunately, I suspect you might not agree with likewise protecting mine. And that is very unfortunate, and (I believe), ultimately self-destructive.

Look at this debate. We're debating. HN is one of the few platforms where this is even possible anymore -- and only because it's sort of back-water and nerdy. Nobody, essentially, reads it (among the world of "normals"). And if they did, it would probably fall to a combination of "Endless September" and political pressure.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by cycrutchfield on Monday May 24, 2021 @01:45PM (#27267417)
Are you confusing Facebook, Google and Twitter for the government? Otherwise I can’t understand how you conclude that free speech rights are being violated.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by pjkundert on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:59PM (#27268356)
The fact that Facebook, Google, Apple, Amazon and Twitter are in total agreement with the current governments of the USA and Canada, and amplify/sink opinions based on their level of compliance with the accepted dogma of both the company and current government -- while simultaneously destroying (Parler) or deplatforming (Gab) any viable alternative platform?
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by cycrutchfield on Monday May 24, 2021 @11:46PM (#27272396)
That’s funny, because from what I recall both Parler and Gab incidents happened during a GOP administration that totally controlled all three branches of government.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by skavi on Monday May 24, 2021 @01:23PM (#27267131)
How exactly is this connected to TFA?
[dead]
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by skavi on Monday May 24, 2021 @01:32PM (#27267251)
I am beginning to doubt you actually read the article. In any case, are you trying to compare India to North Korea?