News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Type 2 diabetes cure, extreme diet by zacharypinter on Sunday June 26, 2011 @10:36PM (#2699873)
Asking for evidence is hardly an ignorant statement. I'd be happy to hear the evidence, it's just that claims like the above tend to set off a radar.
Re:Type 2 diabetes cure, extreme diet by G3P on Sunday June 26, 2011 @10:40PM (#2699888)
Zach, I was responding to rvann's statement, not yours. The "reply" button wasn't available on his for some reason.
Re:Type 2 diabetes cure, extreme diet by zacharypinter on Sunday June 26, 2011 @10:41PM (#2699890)
Ah, thanks for the clarification G3P.
Re:Type 2 diabetes cure, extreme diet by tellitlikeitis on Sunday June 26, 2011 @10:36PM (#2699874)
Since you claim Max Gerson was "a complete quack", does that mean that people who were helped by following the advice of eating fresh fruits and vegetables to the exclusion of other foods (which almost nobody does) were just coincindentally made healthier? And we should dismiss that advice because you don't like Gerson?

What would you recommend their diet consist of if they want to prevent ill health or gain health?

Ignore diet because Gerson was a quack? And just hope they don't get sick? And if they do, come to you for you to select what drugs you deem to have the least conflict of interest at the time?

Do healthy and sick people a favor, and keep your "intellectual" clown bullying from encouraging them to ignore the daily factors that accumulate to become their health or ill health over years.

Re:Type 2 diabetes cure, extreme diet by G3P on Sunday June 26, 2011 @10:47PM (#2699902)
No, it means that he invented treatment regiments that weren't supported by any scientific evidence, and did so while failing to document or properly control any of his "studies," some of which were repeated and found to be not only no better than placebo, but actually harmful to patients.

If I call Dr. X a fraud because he claims coffee enemas are a great way to clear the body of cancer (Such as, say... Max Gerson did), yet Dr. X also believes that drinking water is necessary to sustain life, it doesn't follow that I don't believe drinking water is a great way to stay alive.