There were real philosophical disagreements, and I'm not even saying RMS had the wrong side of the argument. But he definitely gave everyone a huge incentive to go off and do something different because at least you wouldn't be working with RMS.
I can think of several people off the top of my head who attempted to work with RMS, were immediately repelled, and then went off to do other things with freely distributed software.
As for 'bifurcation': it happened because different people have different goals when they release their software. Some are driven by some idealistic values, others do it because it fits in their business plan for whatever reasons. Thus different groups of people might have different requirements to freedoms they grant to their code.
In turn, desperate people who cling at the position for emotional reasons are not all that great.