News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:The Deno Company by ivan888 on Monday March 29, 2021 @10:34AM (#26622248)
I think you took the wrong tone from the parent comment; it sounds like this person was genuinely interested in sparking a real conversation about how people feel about the environment that they spend time in, and whether that could have dramatically shifted based on what they decided to or had to learn
Re:The Deno Company by otde on Monday March 29, 2021 @10:49AM (#26622514)
I feel like if this person was interested in “sparking a conversation,” they wouldn’t open said conversation with “I hate how bloated web abstractions are, but I guess they’re popular for some reason,” with the exact same digs at electron that have been rehashed in every HN comment section.

I agree, to be clear — I use many of said abstractions, and they’re often quite bloated and everything else this person is complaining about. This just doesn’t strike me as someone who’s asking for insight; it’s just complaining, and it’s fine to point that out.

Re:The Deno Company by 40four on Monday March 29, 2021 @11:08AM (#26622856)
Others said they didn't get the same tone as I did, so maybe I'm off there. I'm willing to reconsider.

I'll just give my opinion on the final sentence which I guess is the conversation we should be on.

"And the thing is, I don’t know if I just learned web dev if I would love this new approach to software that is eating the world and I would “get it”. Or if it just exists because JavaScript developers don’t want to learn something new."

I think the answer to this is a resounding "No, if you're not a web developer you will not 'just get it'".

I don't think one approach or the other is 'better', but it just depends on what your background is and how you got into programming, and that's fine.

These tools are meant for web developers. We are talking about the next iteration of NodeJS here. It's the whole point is that it merges web programming with systems programming. So if you're not a web developer, there really is no good reason to jump over unless you are just curious.

From the blog post: "The Deno company hopes to enable the millions of web programmers out there to maximally leverage their craft in other domains."

Re:The Deno Company by rpdillon on Monday March 29, 2021 @10:41AM (#26622381)
> Respectfully, your comment is way off topic, and nothing to do with discussing The Deno Company,

My take from reading the blog post was that the Deno Company's entire thesis is that the developer community will increasingly be moving away from these older abstractions and towards web-based abstractions, and Deno is positioning itself to fuel that migration. GP's comment addresses this directly; it seems rather on-topic to my reading.

Re:The Deno Company by 40four on Monday March 29, 2021 @11:14AM (#26622964)
Fair enough. But I don't see it as the community will be moving away from older approaches. The old ways will always be there. I see it as this is a on-ramp for web developers to get into systems programming.

The reality is there is a huge wave of new developers in the last decade who entered into programming through web. I guess the OP sees this a 'threat' to his way of doing things somehow, but I don't think it's a threat at all. Normal to feel that way though.

These tools are meant for web developers, and if you are not one that's okay. There is probably no good reason to make the jump unless you are just curious or bored.

Last sentence of the blog post: "The Deno company hopes to enable the millions of web programmers out there to maximally leverage their craft in other domains."

Re:The Deno Company by 55555 on Monday March 29, 2021 @10:41AM (#26622382)
When I read the parent comment I didn't infer any of the spite you seem to have felt. It's an interesting question, rephrased: "Is this the best way forward? Or is it only better because people don't need to learn a new language? What are the advantages and disadvantages? Will my current approach to development go out of fashion?"
Re:The Deno Company by 40four on Monday March 29, 2021 @10:51AM (#26622557)
Fair enough, maybe I misinterpreted. But things like "Or if it just exists because JavaScript developers don’t want to learn something new", are very divisive. As if there is something different about Javascript developers that make them lazy, and C programmers are infinitely curious and learn everything new they can.

Edit:

I don't believe one way or the other 'better' technically speaking. Usually the 'best' way forward is the one you have the most skill in. So yes, the one you don't need to learn a new language. Tools like Deno are designed for web developers. Just because they are popular and you hear about them a lot doesn't mean someone else's way of doing things it threatened.