News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by michaelt on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:35PM (#25562396)
Aw man, you are going to be so mad when you find out the % of software developer effort that goes into adtech and entertainment.

Because I guarantee you, for every developer working on a sex toy there a thousand working on selling lootboxes to 12 year olds, and ten thousand working on showing adverts to people who'd rather not see them.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by asxd on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:30PM (#25562358)
I think the reason you’re getting downvoted is pretty much that you’re trying to impose your ideals on others. Some people likely benefit from this library. Some people benefit from the latest video game. If we were all working on curing cancer, the sad truth is that there wouldn’t be very many fun things in life.
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by dazzawazza on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:39PM (#25562445)
Having a life worth living is something a lot of people forget to do.
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by morlockabove on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:12PM (#25562717)
If we all worked on things as important as curing cancer, we could build god and live happily forever. Whichever generation manages this will 'win'. (Or they build a paperclipper and ruin the lightcone.)
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by t-writescode on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:45PM (#25565250)
I imagine they said the same thing about trying to find something to kill scary things that get into our bodies and kill us from easy-to-die-to diseases.

I see the world has not built god and lived happily, forever, after antibiotics were discovered and used. Something else that's horrible will come along and human tendencies will still prevail and exploit others.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by morlockabove on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:30AM (#25567869)
Modus tollens, modus ponens; my quality of life is vastly improved by not dying of smallpox and equivalent improvements to the world would be very valuable. I think going back to a situation with smallpox would be a big decrease, so that argues against things not really getting better.

Building god's just the end-example, even if you never get there you can keep making things better.

(I should say that by "build god" I just mean build a friendly AI, i.e. automate science. If that's impossible, just try and do what it would do.)

(Hard to enjoy your sex toys when you're coughing your lungs out!)

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by aprescott on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:09PM (#25562142)
I have no real opinion on the project in question but devotion is not a fungible, generically applicable resource you decide to apply to one issue or another. Run a test for whatever "IQ/g-factor/ability" handwave you're referencing on someone that loves their work and someone that doesn't.
[dead]
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by not_knuth on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:29PM (#25562867)
I can not help but detect a condescending tone in your comments (if such is not the case, my apologies – Poe's Law and all) and find it interesting that you have not provided sources to the "research" which your claims are based on.

I think it would benefit everybody if you could share a couple of links to some "research".

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by nl on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:07PM (#25564937)
Do you complain this much when a AAA video game is released?
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by henearkr on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:25PM (#25562309)
Happy humans are less likely to wage war.

So, lowering frustration and helping raising levels of serotonin and endorphins, even by using tech, is intrinsically good for the world.

Also, it seems that an active sex life (be it with tech or not) is not dangerous for health.

The only reserve could be the tech pollution of badly discarded toys etc, but that has solutions.

PS: Also -- bodily happiness can improve creativity, thus actually indirectly helping advances in other scientific domains.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by morlockabove on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:14PM (#25562737)
Are sex toys alone actually fulfilling to most people? Given the number of people on thw internet complaining about misery from sexual loneliness, it clearly isn't enough.

Sex toys, porn, and enculturing cowardice stave off the war, I guess. You just get Elliot Roger instead.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by t-writescode on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:50PM (#25565282)
Did you know that couples can and do use sex toys? There's a whole industry for it!

And, with long-distance relationships, smart sex-toys can facilitate the more intimate times in a more fulfilling way than standard phone or type-sex.

A loving and committed couple could, while apart due to, perhaps, a conference or business trip or anything else, enjoy the company of one-another in that way perfectly well.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by morlockabove on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:27AM (#25567851)
Of course! There's good uses for everything.

It's all this talk of poorly susbtituting emotional bonds with simulacra that annoys me. Seems like a motte-and-bailey.

Oh, it's for couples! Now let's go back to selling our subscription model AI anime girlfriend

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by henearkr on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @01:04PM (#25572687)
And what do you think about people who develop their own AI anime girlfriend? Even sharing their work as free software libraries?

In your wording it only looks like it is the exploitation of people by businessmen selling the happiness as a product, whereas it can actually be the user themselves developing it for their purposes (like when it's opensource, hackable, or even DIY, etc).

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by morlockabove on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:41AM (#25582055)
I'm a lot more sympathetic to someone who manufactures their own drugs for personal consumption, yes, but only because the difficulty involved means you need a minimum of discipline to get there which would hopefully meliorate the negative effects of the habit. It's in the same vein as writing games being more virtuous (to yourself) than playing them.

Anyway, my vision of the future is hundreds of millions of obese NEETS who spend their entire monthly UBI check on overpriced insect-protein food, clothing, video, porn and AI girlfriend-as-a-service products. Pigs at the trough, given just enough slop that they don't kill themselves, while the people who can resist temptation (say, helped along by their upbringing) get to be human.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by henearkr on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:50PM (#25589060)
I think that all your objections boil down to "instant gratification does not harness the brain's reward system as a motivation to achieve difficult things and improve general intellectual/physical/social abilities".

It is true, but somewhat orthogonal to other problems such as how to reach happiness. As an intellectual leaning person, I tend (like you) to link my own happiness to greater ability of my mind, but that is absolutely not generalizable. For some other people, the notion is true but only regarding "to improve physical abilities", and they don't care about the other parameters. etc.

Moreover, the highlighted problem of instant gratification thus applies not only to sexual needs, but also to feeding needs, for example. It would be interesting to compare foraging/hunting societies with ours in this regard.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by henearkr on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:42PM (#25562992)
The connectedness of the new generation of toys, combined with worlds such as VRChat, are contributing to make the loneliness of "not skin-to-skin sex" a thing of the past.

Also you start to see (unmanned) virtual characters sophisticated enough to trigger emotions of love, and in some case commitment. It is clearly still extreme and a bit too early, but in the near future I can see people becoming really in fond of their virtual AI character partner.

We agree that not only immediate endorphins levels, but also mid and long term serotonin levels, are important for happiness, and I think that this connected tech is helping in the right way.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by qdot76367 on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:50PM (#25563076)
VRChat via a few different plugins (that I should really link from my awesome-buttplug repo) makes up a BIG chunk of my users.

Which kinda makes me sad because VRC is an absolute nightmare to work with. Can we please all move to NeosVR? :3

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by justsupersayin on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @12:43AM (#25567098)
If that is the society you are building, it deserves to be mercilessly destroyed.
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by henearkr on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @12:57PM (#25572582)
On what basis?

And, I'm not personally building any of this, it just already exists, and some people are enjoying it.

Heck, it is even being developed and hacked by the users themselves, when it is hackable, like in this very HN post.

Sounds like you just want everybody to be happy only your way...

Even without this kind of tech, the paths for happiness are probably beyond everything your little window of a mind can imagine.

PS: it looks like somebody has called their local church's friends to retaliate on this how unholly HN thread, and they come up here and create new accounts and answer my comments without even realizing that I am not the OP...

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by morlockabove on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:39PM (#25563544)
Sounds like hell. Nothing personal, but I really hope your enterprise fails miserably.
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by henearkr on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:42PM (#25563566)
It's what some people need.

People who don't need it just won't use it.

It's not a "smoker / passive smoker" effect, they will not disturb other people.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by morlockabove on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:54PM (#25563682)
Some people need heroin. I'm against the war on drugs, but I still despise dealers.
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by henearkr on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:56PM (#25563705)
But in the case of heroin there are huge side-effects on health of the user and on the security of the surrounding people.
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by johnisgood on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:27PM (#25566032)
I know someone who takes it on a daily basis. You would not be able to tell that he uses. It makes him productive (he works in IT), he takes it to combat anxiety and depression. It works for him. He voluntarily goes through withdrawal occasionally so he will not have to increase the dose. He is in a healthy relationship, and so forth. He might be an exception, I do not know.

All the side-effects are a result from the War on Drugs: not knowing the purity of the batch, adultered products, and so forth. This is why accidental overdoses happen. This is why it is bad for your health for the most part, because God knows with what it is mixed. Intentional overdoses happen too, but that happens with OTC medications, too, so heroin is not so special in that regard.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by henearkr on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:56PM (#25566237)
Thanks, yes that's true that if the {legal, moral, medical} context was better most of the problem would be gone. People able to workaround the difficulties of this drug may well be fine.

My point was that, in the current context, the use or heroin is hazardous -- in our current society, for most people -- which is not the case for virtual sex and related toys (if not horribly dysfunctional).

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by johnisgood on Monday December 28, 2020 @10:05PM (#25566297)
Yeah, he does not use it for recreational purposes or escapism, so I believe that changes a lot. He has been doing it for years without any side-effects. He had MRI, blood tests, and so on. Everything's good.

I do not know much about virtual sex. What are the possibilities and limitations of virtual sex today?

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by henearkr on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:28PM (#25566722)
I do not work in this field and I don't know much (maybe better ask qdot76367), but I've discovered recently that VRChat ERP is a thing.

Not virtual but still weird in another dimension, there are also animated realistic sex dolls.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by johnisgood on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:36PM (#25566776)
On Kickstarter I have seen some 3D holograph device that projected you in 3D. It looked kinda realistic, that would probably be interesting, too.
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by morlockabove on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:36AM (#25568194)
You mention "horribly dysfunctional" further down. That's what I have a problem with.

I see these cardboard sex-simulacra trapping, for example, young men in local optima where they never go and talk to a real girl- even young men who could, if they tried, and who'd be happier in the end for it.

Anything that increases the number of incels in the world is a bad thing, for everyone.

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by qdot76367 on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:46PM (#25565257)
looks at you

looks at Project Melody

I got some bad news.

(This is not to say I'm pro-virtual-emodel or whatever the current name for this is, but it's definitely a thing, and it's definitely popular)

Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by morlockabove on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:42AM (#25567925)
Yeah, I know it's big. I just don't like it. I guess I'm raging against the future that seems to be coming- I'm finally old!
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by scpedicini on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:40PM (#25562457)
No thanks, I'd rather make out with my Monroe bot.
Re:Buttplug (Sex Toy Control Library) Hits v1 Milestone by qdot76367 on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:52PM (#25562546)
We'll hopefully have Monroe bot hardware support in an upcoming version of the library.