Now, seriously, I always doubted he would be captured alive. Just imagine how embarrassing would it be all the information about the CIA operations during the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan becoming public on a trial. Of course he resisted capture.
As for embarrassment, who said he'd ever be put on trial if we had him? If we can hold his followers indefinitely, certainly we could hold him.
If you were in a dark room and burst in on a trained soldier in a baggy robe, would you wait to see if he had a gun/knife/grenade within range? If he did anything other than lay straight down on the floor with his hands up, it could be perceived as threatening.
I'm not trying to comment on whether that response is ethical, but it seems totally plausible to me.
If you're a criminal and the police burst into your house then the police can't (or at least, aren't allowed to) shoot you unless they have damn good reason to believe that their lives are in danger. In a war, though, if you're an enemy combatant then you're fair game unless you're actively surrendering.
There's some gray area between the two, somewhere, but as a general rule if you want to steer clear of the latter category then don't make a video in which you "declare war on the United States" and then start killing people.
Indeed. Even if he is alive, he's dead. At least until Al Qaeda is effectively neutralized.
He could have released such information without facing a trial. What you suspect makes entirely no sense.
Whether anybody has been listening (yet) is another matter.