News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by ibuildthings on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:50AM (#24965120)
In this particular case, why is testing/demonstrating on diverse set of individuals a bad thing ?

A personal anecdote is that a few years back the automatic door sensors in my university did not work on my skin tone.

Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by easytiger on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:48AM (#24965897)
Automatic door sensors are in my experience universally infra red. In fact I don't think I've ever seen any camera technology used in that context. Are you saying they used cameras to open the doors?
Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by ZephyrBlu on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:58AM (#24965153)
It's not a bad thing, I just dislike that I noticed it.
Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by gexla on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:42AM (#24965316)
It's video conferencing software. Makes sense that they might put together imagery which might suggest people meeting from different corners of the planet. But sure, I get your point. I didn't notice this myself, but I have been living on side of the planet opposite from where I was born for the past decade.
Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by mdoms on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:54AM (#24965138)
Why don't you like it?
Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by ZephyrBlu on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:59AM (#24965157)
Because I don't think I would have noticed a couple of years ago.
Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by dharma1 on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:58AM (#24965155)
Sorry not everyone on the planet looks like you
Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by hombre_fatal on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:24AM (#24965260)
They seem to be lamenting that they now notice skin color (due to all the racial essentialism of the last N years) where they used to not notice.
Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by riffraff on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:44AM (#24965326)
I understand the feeling somewhat: it is very noticeable how TV shows for example now have expanded the default cast from "all white people + token black, maybe a gay individual" to "all white people + token black woman + token asian + token non-binary, maybe a transgender individual".

It feels forced and ham-fisted, but I don't see how this could be made in a better way.

Possibly people growing up with this will not notice it at all, and it will be good for them, it's only us old farts that need to adapt.

Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by ZephyrBlu on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:25AM (#24965483)
Unfortunately I'm Gen Z, not an old fart :/.

No clue how most Gen Z people feel about this type of thing though.

Re:Background Features in Google Meet, Powered by Web ML by saurik on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:02AM (#24965389)
I think the issue is that, were it not for everyone being forced to notice, everyone was defaulting to caring so little that we just used the people around us or who we had existing connections with (for demos, training data, employees... whatever), and everything was horribly biased due to numerous reasons. So, while before you weren't being forced to pay attention, everything was more racist than now, where you are being forced to actually make an effort to be anti-racist.

To put this into a programming metaphor, to me this is like being triggered by someone going out of their way to add a buffer overflow check due to a bunch of people spending the last decade screaming about buffer overflow security issues. Sure, before you didn't have to notice, but your code was probably also horribly insecure; now, everyone gets angry if you don't take at least minimal precautions, and people are even advocating that you use more secure languages from the start (to the point of questioning your architectural decisions if you don't), so you are being forced to pay attention--and sure, it seems a bit annoying and like extra work that a bunch of fanatics are foisting on you, and if someone had taken the time for their code to be secure before you might not have noticed (I mean, you weren't ever against security) but now it is screaming at you "this is because of those annoying security people rubbing our noses in our buffer overflows" so you get angry because this is taking time away from "getting the real work done" on your product--but the reality is that your code used to have glaring security issues that affected people who weren't you, and it sucked; everyone is better off for you paying attention now, and maybe one day we can fix the systemic problem and no one will have to put in such obvious effort to avoid being part of the problem, but we clearly aren't there yet. Being angry about this just comes off as not giving a shit about security: you didn't notice these checks before, because the code was just as good to you, for the criteria you were bothering to pay attention to, without the checks as it would have been with them, and the whole point is that that wasn't true... it was actually much worse; similarly, being angry about people making active efforts to have diversity in product advertising frankly just makes you come off as not giving a shit about minority representation :/.