News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:RaspberryPi 4 home lab with LXD cluster by herpderperator on Saturday October 03, 2020 @02:24AM (#24670040)
As others have correctly pointed out, this is a fun, ongoing project on server clusters built using real hardware with real limitations. My laptop from 2018 has 64GB RAM... and would it even matter to say that I already have several high-performance machines? I am not sure what your point is. I did not buy Raspberry Pis to save money, I bought them to have a bunch of small physical servers to play around with. I could have easily started 8 VMs bridged to the network in the same way with virt-manager/QEMU and got 8 much more powerful Linux instances for free if that's what I wanted.
Re:RaspberryPi 4 home lab with LXD cluster by fapjacks on Saturday October 03, 2020 @03:45AM (#24670355)
Like looking at a jeweler's workshop and asking "Why all these shitty little hammers? Don't you know how well a sledge works?"
Re:RaspberryPi 4 home lab with LXD cluster by hddherman on Saturday October 03, 2020 @02:07AM (#24669949)
I'm sure that if their goal was a fast server with a modern CPU, then they would have gone for it.

I see their project as a fun hobby. It's very fun to put a lot of tiny low-power computers together in a cluster and learn as you go. Sure, you should take into account the limitations, but you should not feel discouraged if all you want to do is to have fun, learn and build something that is quite unique.

Re:RaspberryPi 4 home lab with LXD cluster by jacquesm on Saturday October 03, 2020 @05:21AM (#24670733)
And I'm sick of people pissing on other people's nice projects out of envy or malice. Why don't you simply fuck off? Flagged.
Re:RaspberryPi 4 home lab with LXD cluster by oarsinsync on Saturday October 03, 2020 @05:20AM (#24670727)
In terms of raw compute, you're absolutely right.

In terms of understanding distributed computing and the failure modes that can occur, the GP's approach is definitely better. If you build distributed systems only testing them through virtualisation, you'll run into all sorts of issues that come from adding real world constraints that are otherwise masked through the virtualised abstraction.

Re:RaspberryPi 4 home lab with LXD cluster by barumi on Saturday October 03, 2020 @05:27AM (#24670767)
This post just adds noise to an otherwise interesting discussion while missing the whole point of learning how to set up a cluster.

Even the tone itself is non-constructive, all wrong and off-putting.

I'm sure you can understand that someone who bolts on computers over WiFi and praises a 100MB/s connection is not aiming for performance.

This is not what HN is all about.

Re:RaspberryPi 4 home lab with LXD cluster by panpanna on Saturday October 03, 2020 @02:08AM (#24669950)
Most pi clusters are created for learning devops theologies.

Speaking of that, happy to see LXD on the front page. Its not as hyped as Docker but I really like it.

Re:RaspberryPi 4 home lab with LXD cluster by danmur on Saturday October 03, 2020 @02:06AM (#24669937)
Burn :P

One small thing they're nice for is if you want to play with a cluster (e.g. nomad, kubernetes, whatever) on a budget. Of course it's not going to be great bang for buck just for performance but if you're trying out some distributed computing it's nice to be working to real limitations, network and RAM and particular.