Regarding that drama
https://www.wetheweb.org/post/cancel-we-the-web
https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/
https://twitter.com/thomas_lord/status/1174433654942007297
https://geoff.greer.fm/2019/09/30/in-defense-of-richard-stal...
https://medium.com/@whoisylvia/richard-stallman-has-been-vil...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20990583
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21120806
ESR once explained to me that he simply didn't understand/value the "social overhead" needed in terms of conventional civility. I told ESR then he should expect unconventional outcomes/responses to his antics, including his profound failures at basic hygiene and not being a creepy GNU-hobo.
I respect his technical accomplishments, but he's always expressed himself as a torpid, obstinate, schmuck.
ESR basically wanted to take credit for RMS' work and co-opt the movement. It was some pretty nasty stuff.
That is not fair.
I read most of ESR's writings in the late 1990s after he started the Open Source Initiative and attended one of his talks, and I never heard or read anything from him that could be interpreted as trying to take credit for RMS's accomplishments.
Although ESR contradicted some of RMS's messaging, there would be much much less open-source software in the world if RMS had somehow been able to control all the messaging around the movement.
He only has the position, what you call his privilege, because of his principles.
>he refuses to use Google Docs to read the deposition, so he asks someone else to use Google Docs to download it for him.
Sounds similar to tikotiparisuddha. Stallman seems very enlightened. He has pure principles regarding the four freedoms, but does not tyrannically demand you obey them. You are welcome to give up your freedom, even though he never will.
The short answer is because they're different. The angry answer is that you may as well be asking why there isn't a "white history month" (I mean, if all we're doing is swapping colors, it should be good, right?).
The longer answer from scholars who study racism is that talking about race boundaries without talking about power structures is a con game. At best it's facile. The people who study it the most (historians and philosophers of race) define racism not just in terms of skin color prejudice but primarily in terms of power structures that protect the interests of the dominant group and discriminate against minorities. In those terms, while an individual can be prejudiced against white men, no political or economic power actively oppresses white men as a class.
Instead of thinking only about skin color prejudice, you can consider racism to be a condition in society in which a dominant racial group benefits from the oppression of others. Racist behavior is thus those behaviors that perpetuate, propagate, and preserve the oppression of racial minorities.
[I guess someone doesn't like my answer. Man, HN is really tiresome sometimes.]
No thanks.
I did the "travel the world at other people's expense" thing for a bit too. My experience is that an international trip every 2 months is just about as much as I can handle before my mental health starts slipping. There's a huge difference between going to conferences 1-4 times per year (which is fun!), and living on airplanes.
Having earned through great personal inconvenience, and social adversity, existing in a world whilst coping with a significant degree of neuroatypicality, you might actually find some level of refuge and respite amongst other similarly minded individuals.
Imagine the gall of the individual that would look at every scrap of adversity you took upon yourself for the sake of others instead of just going with the flow and letting the world be carved up between vested non-free software imterests, to call you unjustifiably privileged for the supporting shoulders you've received as a token thank you for at least living the ideal we all wish we could.
Honestly, at this point, I just think that people just despise seeing other people helped by other people, or otherwise succeeding in spite of their own adversity/weirdness/atypicality. It's quite hypocritical considering that this claim of privilege seems to come with the inherent demonstration that someone else would be better served by it. Controversial ideas or no, he's done more to keep software free and accessible than just about anyone else on the planet. He's not responsible for software being "unwelcoming" to outsiders either. Outsiders being unable or unwilling to understand subculture humor more than anything else is responsible for half of that; and the entire backbone of the Hacker ethos being that one is responsible for the banishment of one's own ignorance is the other half. No one is owed inclusion or admittance. No one is owed the context that makes one off color comment or another humorous to the author. Thus the treasure that is actually learning why it was the way it was.
No one gets a free pass. You make something cool, you learn, teach, or contribute something; you figure something out or generally offer something to the community that makes it a better place? Then you're in, you know it, and no one can ever take it away from you. Not that certain groups, mostly adherents of cancel culture won't try; and have found some success. Even those successes too will soon pass, as the community splinters along the new schism. The adherents of the old ways following the old ways, and the cancel culture people going on to form their own bubble.
This is extremely uncharitable. If you would ask him if he is "pretty okay" with anything of what you accuse him, he would likely be shocked that you think that about him. And if I had access to every internet discussion you ever had or mail you ever sent, how much "problematic" stuff would I find?
Scanning Stallmans political notes page (which is going back decades) Stallman comes across as consistently anti-authoritarian, leftist, pacifist and, yes, feminist:
https://www.stallman.org/archives/2020-may-aug.html
RMS comes from a different libertarian and egalitarian world, which is sadly vanishing, the world of electronic bulletin board systems, usenet, the early internet culture, where you could discuss anything freely, sometimes playing advocatus diaboli to explore interesting discussions or line of reasoning. This online culture is changing (or already changed) sadly and political correct feelings are counting more now than logic and arguments.
I read that post and I do not see anything horrible about it. He makes a fair point regarding the use of term sexual assault or characterizing the teen as a child.
> In 1993, he asked for birth announcements to be banned from emacs mailing list, unless they are announcements for seahorses, because then it would be the male that gives birth and therefore interesting.
I do not see what is weird with that either. Would you be interested in birth announcements in your gitlab issue tracker?
> but still implies that people with Trisomy 21 should not be born
Yes, he has an opinion that he does a good job justifying. So what?
Everyone made their minds already on this one. Please move on!
What a horrible thing to say about someone, 'deplorable software celebrity' or not. Attacks on personal appearance should be considered body shaming and unacceptable. It is generally best to imagine you're in a professional setting when talking about people.