Spain may have reduced deaths in the short term, but there's no particular reason it hasn't just spread them over a longer period of time. You can't eradicate this disease permanently without closing your borders permanently.
You don't need to estimate, you only need to look at the facts. In Spain the covid outbreak forced them to comandeer hotels to serve as intensive care units and even then they were compelled to open an emergency hospital in Madrid with capacity for 5000 patients just to be able to admit covid19 patients requiring immediate medical care.
And that alone was just to alleviate their healthcare system.
The first option is not on the table with covid19 because asymptomatic and presymptomaric carriers can walk freely among us weeks at a time without anyone having a clue.