The US government is not responsible for the emergence of the epidemic. The US government is definitely responsible for the policy responses in the US that have shaped the course of its emergence here.
And we can see that several governments that are not China have handled a threat that emerged outside their borders and about which they presumably had no better access to information about... much better than we have.
Maybe there's blame to cast on China, but it's a lot more productive for citizens of each country to hold their own governments to account.
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/19/world/coronav...
The only countries that appear to have handled it better are South Korea and Japan.
If I mixed up the charts for the US and other nations except those and Italy (which is much worse), you wouldn't be able to tell which is which.
So when you say:
> The US government is definitely responsible for the policy responses in the US that have shaped the course of its emergence here.
I wonder what you mean. The shape of its emergence here is exactly like the shape of its emergence in a dozen other countries.
Denmark were very good at testing widely initially and have subsequently changed the criteria for who gets tested to only be for those presenting with acute symptoms. I haven't been able to find out why they changed but my assumption is limited testing capacity and they're preparing for an increase in the number of cases so want to prioritise.
I will be very interested at the end of this to see how Denmark's response is rated, but it does feel like they have been among the better performers globally.
That page has the official advice for Denmark, but not necessarily the underlying reasons.
I assume there's a limited supply of tests, and they need to keep enough in stock for predicted future serious cases.
How many better examples would it take before one concludes that it's possible to have done better and there is a responsibility to do so?
I'd say one is adequate.
> If I mixed up the charts for the US and other nations except those and Italy (which is much worse), you wouldn't be able to tell which is which.
Take off the labels and I'd absolutely be able to tell that the countries are divided among:
* those that have a simple exponential curve that tells a story of no effective intervention
* those that have a noisier exponential curve, which suggests a story of either partially effective interventions or some confounding factor
* those that have peaks and valleys, suggesting a story of moving towards containment and then hitting setbacks
* those that have apparently peaked, suggesting a story of effective containment efforts
And we already know which category the US belongs in.
You're just assigning meaning to random noise.
I agree it's possible to do better and we should learn from other nations, but I think it's unrealistic to expect that USA be #1 in everything. Sometimes other nations will do better.
There's many endeavors in which the effectiveness of interventions can change daily, either with the conscientiousness of application, or in changing conditions that need response. On top of that, there's all kinds of systems where an intervention can introduce an oscillating contribution to the output.
I can't see any reason why viral containment responses wouldn't have potential interventions in any of those categories, and there are several good reasons why it's likely, perhaps chief among them that effectiveness of control in any system relies heavily on good data feedback.
> You're just assigning meaning to random noise.
First and foremost I'm describing distinctions between characteristics that show up in the plots you brought to the discussion. Those distinctions aren't speculation, they're there. Your attribution of them to "random noise" is at best just as much speculation as my attribution to intervention differences is. And considering how smooth some of those exponentials are there is almost certainly something functional rather than noisy going on behind them, whether it's something I've already mentioned related to containment efforts, or something else like differences in how continuity of social contact works in parts of the world represented by noisier graphs.
I would note though that blaming other countries is rarely useful, since you have virtually 0 power to influence the decisions of other countries. However, you do have some measure of power to affect the decisions of your own country, so assessing and blaming the response that your own country had is more useful than looking at others.
So you can absolutely say that China deceived the world and deserves our ire. But you should also wonder why the WHO chose to believe the famously information-controlling Chinese authorities, why your own government chose to believe China and the WHO playing its game. You can also choose to ask whether your own government, once the reality of what was happening in China got out, had a fast enough and acute enough response.
The answer will vary by country and by individual assessing this, but it is far more useful than only blaming China. To give some examples of my own opinions, Taiwan, Japan, and SK are probably examples of governments that did most things right so far. Italy and Iran are examples of governments that have done horribly initially but may be rallying now. The UK and the Netherlands are examples of countries that are not reacting well enough even today. As for my own country, I am mostly satisfied with most of the decisions taken, and their timing, though I am concerned with the amount of testing the government is doing. Based on future data on the actual effectiveness, I may end up blaming my own government, if for example the lack of testing proves fatal, and I can act on that blame by voting them out office when I get the next chance.
But for some reason Japan and South Korea were informed and handled the problem, so what conspiracy explains this? Japan has good spies? Japan has supernatural future prediction technology?
According to the timeline of Japan's response in [1], the US responded at the same time as Japan. Their first countermeasure listed in [1] was a travel restriction enacted on February 3, the same time as US restrictions[2,3]
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_J...
2: https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/traveladvisories/...
3: https://www.cnn.com/2020/02/02/us/coronavirus-us-travel-rest...
I am not defending China, just trying to address the blame shifting and maybe convince some people that the next one can originate in their own country and we all need to be better prepared.
This is how arrivals in the US were handled a few days ago, this hall practially is a breeding ground for new infections: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/15/us/airports-coronavirus.h...
My point is NOT Japan good USA bad, I just want to show that there was the option to get a grip on the situation in January.
The past is the past, and every present discussion should focus on things that can be done now.
The question of how is to blame the most can be answered in a year or so, when things have calmed down.
I see two photos of people standing close together. Neither group is practicing social distancing.
The Japanese are wearing masks (not N95 masks) whose effectiveness is still being debated, but that's about custom, not government response.
The photo from America shows a bigger room, but I suspect that's just a choice of photo and Japanese airports had big rooms full of people in January too. Perhaps not, but certainly a photo of a small room doesn't disprove the existence of big rooms.
The current US Airport situation was in the news here in Germany, but perhaps not in the US. It breaks with most distancing guidelines. People are much too close to each other (compared to the advised 1-2m distance), and shared the same room (and air) for many hours. What good is that whole measure if you practically guarantee that more infected people will enter the country afterwards?
My overall point was related to the dates of both posts. Yes, on paper both Japan and the US implemented similar-sounding measures at about the same time. But one has to look at the actual implementation.
But it's not an option right now, there are no face masks available. That's a custom that has to exist before the pandemic starts so people will already have masks.
A friend of mine living in Japan thinks there's a "burying their head in the sand" type mentality going on.
They've only performed 32,000 tests (which is 16,484 people); which makes it hard to know exactly how the disease is spreading there.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-japan-...
Thinking here is Abe/Japan do not want to delay the Olympics, so aren't testing...
Meanwhile in the Trump Administration was actively blocking attempts to perform surveillance by public health authorities as recently as Feb 27th.
[citation needed]
> State health officials joined Chu in asking the CDC and Food and Drug Administration to waive privacy rules and allow clinical tests in a research lab, citing the threat of significant loss of life. The CDC and FDA said no. "We felt like we were sitting, waiting for the pandemic to emerge," Chu told the Times. "We could help. We couldn't do anything." They held off for a couple of weeks, but on Feb. 25, Chu and her colleagues "began performing coronavirus tests, without government approval,"
https://theweek.com/speedreads/901405/seattle-lab-uncovered-...
“The White House considered issuing an executive order greatly expanding the use of investigational drugs against the new coronavirus, but met with objections from Food and Drug Administration scientists who warned it could pose unneeded risks to patients, according to a senior government official.
The idea to expand testing of drugs and other medical therapies was strongly opposed by the FDA’s senior scientists this week, the official said, and represented the most notable conflict between the FDA and the White House in recent memory.”
https://www.wsj.com/articles/trump-sought-to-expand-virus-dr...
So federal regulators (not Trump) told researchers not to test samples from a research study without the patients' permission?
Seems reasonable to me. They should have gotten permission from the participants instead of asking regulators to waive patient privacy.
> as part of a research project into the flu, she and a team of researchers had been collecting nasal swabs from residents experiencing symptoms throughout the Puget Sound region.
> To repurpose the tests for monitoring the coronavirus, they would need the support of state and federal officials. But nearly everywhere Dr. Chu turned, officials repeatedly rejected the idea,
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/10/us/coronavirus-testing-de...
This is false.
They did not jail the doctor.
> Four days later he was summoned to the Public Security Bureau where he was told to sign a letter. In the letter he was accused of "making false comments" that had "severely disturbed the social order".
> "We solemnly warn you: If you keep being stubborn, with such impertinence, and continue this illegal activity, you will be brought to justice - is that understood?" Underneath in Dr Li's handwriting is written: "Yes, I do."
I misunderstood. But the point remains the same, just replace "jailed" with "threatened".
1: https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2020-02-06/corona...
Would you still blame Team B for not knowing about the danger immediately?
And you seem to say Team B is still utterly blameless, it's all Team A's fault.
What do you blame Trump for?
From what I've read, the US response was hindered mostly by a faulty reagent in the CDC's test kits, which led to an inability to test patients for the virus.[1] How is a faulty reagent Trump's fault?
And even with that hinderence, the course of the virus, the number of people hospitalized, and the government policies in the US seem to be proceeding in parallel with most other developed nations.
1: https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/02/united-states-badly-...
> one of the brainwashed
Talk like that isn't appropriate here.
As deng says, this is a place for curious, open-minded discussion, not partisan name calling.
I'd disagree with your claim that you've responded (in my view your "Aaah you're attacking me" is just a deflection), but as I've written, I'm walking away. Enjoy that cognitive dissonance!
Let's not bring that nonsense here. Let's discuss facts and evidence and make an effort to put partisanship aside.
what was Trump doing for the past two months?
would an extra month's notice have done anything? I get the sense Obama could have told him exactly when it would happen, and he'd have still done nothing until American deaths started ramping up
This extends beyond the NSC pandemic response team, one would think the intelligence community would have some insights assuming the rebuilt their Chinese network after the CIA debacle in 2010. This wasn't a natural disaster like Maria or Katrina with limited forecasting, WHO was alerted to on Dec 31st.
E: Though TBH I think US would have waffled regardless, even their response to Ebola, Operation United Assistance, didn't materialize until the first US death on US soil. Things aren't real until they affect votes or undermine foreign policy interests.