News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by scroot on Sunday December 22, 2019 @10:49AM (#21857744)
> What’s inherently bad with differences between poor and rich people?

This is not the argument. Concern rests on the size of the gap, rather than the fact of differences. Greater inequality is associated with many negative properties, such as decreased social trust, declining mortality rates, political instability, etc.

> The poorest people in the planet today have access to more resources than the greatest king had 500 hundred years ago.

Is the new bar going to be 500 years ago?

> Are you saying you would like all of us to be equally poor?

...What?

> To me this sounds more like jealousy and virtue signaling than anything else.

Are you suggesting that a concern for mounting inequality is a form of jealousy? And to the extent that what you say about signaling is true, I'd take a whole heaping pile of "virtue signaling" over bad faith reactionary arguments to very real and very dangerous social problems.

Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by kilroy_jones on Sunday December 22, 2019 @11:38AM (#21858095)
How can you say that wealth is not a zero sum game when resources are finite?

It's bad because wealth provides power, and power is currently being wielded to take away the autonomy of those who are poorer. Economic means are used by the obscenely wealthy to do some pretty horrid things, from buying elections to covering up their child sweatshop operations. Wealth inequality rapidly leads to general inequality in the eyes of the state.

Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by matthewmacleod on Sunday December 22, 2019 @10:50AM (#21857753)
First off, you’re wrong. “The poorest people on the planet” in no way have access to “more resources than the greatest king had 500 years ago”. It’s self-evidently nonsense.

Second, massive inequality between rich and poor is a signal that something has gone horribly wrong with the distribution of wealth generated by society. That does not mean that “all of us need to be poor”. It does indicate that the rewards of civilisation have been unevenly distributed.

Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by sokoloff on Sunday December 22, 2019 @12:08PM (#21858284)
> Second, massive inequality between rich and poor is a signal that something has gone horribly wrong with the distribution of wealth generated by society.

Is it? It seems to me like a world where a small group of people can improve the lives of a wide swath of the population (as measured and evidenced by that wide swath of people willingly giving them money in exchange for goods/services), that it’s fairly natural and even desirable for those creators of value to retain some of it for themselves.

Perhaps the relatively new capability of efficient global transportation and widespread Internet communication allows small groups to improve the lives of even larger groups than they could 50, 100, or 250 years ago.

We should celebrate that lives are improved broadly rather than excoriating those who are providing the improvements in exchange for money.

Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by scroot on Sunday December 22, 2019 @12:58PM (#21858568)
What are the improvements? Who is providing them and how?
Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by sokoloff on Sunday December 22, 2019 @01:08PM (#21858621)
When I give money to a merchant, I do so because they have improved my life. Whether it’s a gallon of gas, a gallon of milk, a car, a month of cell phone service, doesn’t matter.
Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by logicchains on Sunday December 22, 2019 @11:04AM (#21857863)
>Second, massive inequality between rich and poor is a signal that something has gone horribly wrong with the distribution of wealth generated by society. That does not mean that “all of us need to be poor”. It does indicate that the rewards of civilisation have been unevenly distributed.

What is the "right" distribution then? Given that wealth invested will grow exponentially, it seems pretty self-evident that people who invest wealth will end up with way more wealth then people who don't. Even in a very simple model where half the population invests 30% of their savings and the other invests 10%, over a few decades the former will end up massively wealthier than the latter. Similarly, if both halves invest the same amount but one is able to find investments with 10% return and the other with 2% return, the former will end up way wealthier. What's unnatural about this?

Hence if we assume people have different degrees of preference for and competence at investing (there's no reason to assume these traits don't vary), we'd expect that even if everyone started from the same position some would end up way wealthier than others.

Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by mcguire on Sunday December 22, 2019 @12:06PM (#21858270)
Fortunately, of course, excessive wealth and power disparities are reset periodically by major wars (WWI/2, the French Revolution, the Thirty Years War,...) and other civilizational upheavals (out on a limb, but the collapse of the Roman Empire).

Of course, many people regard that sort of thing as something to avoid.

Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by scroot on Sunday December 22, 2019 @11:12AM (#21857924)
Read Piketty
Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by sametmax on Sunday December 22, 2019 @12:04PM (#21858252)
It's not a matter of morality, politic leaning or envy. We collectively agree, as a human specy, that fairness, equality and democracy are quality we want to cultivate.

A high difference between rich and poor is a sign of power concentrating, which is the opposite of what you want for democracy. It also means resources are getting less and less evenly distributed. If you aim for more fairness and equality, you need the reversed trend. Eventually, it means exhibit symptoms of being optimized for economic efficiency and a certain part of the population, while we know monoculture is not in favor of the specie on the long run.

Re:We've Just Had the Best Decade in Human History by ben_w on Sunday December 22, 2019 @11:03AM (#21857856)
Although it is true that wealth is not a zero-sum game, the poorest in the world today are essentially as poor now as they were 500 years ago. Extreme poverty, defined as less than $1.90/day, still affects 734 million people in 2016. This is a massive improvement, but it’s still a thing. The poorest in developed nations might be richer than the monarchs of 1519 by all counts except land and slave ownership (and gold, and political power), but the world doesn’t stop at the borders of the G20.

Unfortunately, it seems that it is still bad to have relative poverty even in the absence of absolute poverty, as it leads to political and civil unrest. Calling it jealousy doesn’t make it go away. Likewise, you can call anything you don’t like “virtue signalling”, so it’s not got any predictive power unless you want to be more precise.