News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by CydeWeys on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:27AM (#20075292)
People are mobile. What would actually happen would be the biggest refugee crisis the world has ever seen.

Imagine tens of millions of climate refugees at the border of many different countries, and the choice is to let them in and take care of them or let them die right there. It's not a good situation to be in.

Realistically speaking, with that many people, good luck keeping them out.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by Sharlin on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:51AM (#20075434)
It's really interesting how this doesn't seem to occur to some people even in this HN discussion, even in the context of the recent refugee waves to Europe and the illegal immigration situation in the US. Boggles the mind that someone would think that entire populations would just… lay down and die or something!
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by noir_lord on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:35AM (#20075342)
I remember reading a sci-fi story back in the 80's (damn I wish I could remember the name) where that basically happened, Europe and the US fortified their borders (massive walls/fences, automated weapon systems, usual sci-fi fare) and left the rest of the world to it's own devices.

I was only a kid and I remember thinking "I can't imagine that ever happening" then I look at the refugee camps in EU states (Greece particularly) and it doesn't seem so far fetched.

Trump and his wall as well.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by wongarsu on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:26AM (#20075643)
If some of the worse projections become true and large stretches of land become uninhabitable or very inhospitable my money is on the US deploying semi-automated machine gun turrets along the border wall: the turrets will have automated target aquisition and tracking but a minimum-wage border patrol agent in an office in Austin will have to confirm the kill decision. It will be about as controversial as the drone program. Meanwhile in the EU the discussion will be around the coast guard shooting African refugee ships instead of rescuing them.

The only real winner will be Russia: they can just absorb all the refugees from South Asia and use them to populate then-inhabitable Syberia.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by Mediterraneo10 on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:11AM (#20075952)
> The only real winner will be Russia: they can just absorb all the refugees from South Asia

Ethnic Russians are already concerned about plunging birthrates. It is not at all unusual to hear elected Russian officials talk about “the future of the white race”. Furthermore, Russians are aware that a decline in the ethnic Russian population means that the local Muslim minorities gain a correspondingly higher share of the country. Thus, the topic is already a very pressing and sensitive one, and it would be silly to suggest that Russia is open to admitting masses of Muslim (or Hindu) refugees.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by rini17 on Sunday June 02, 2019 @12:01PM (#20076249)
Not really, thawing permafrost is unsuitable for building any modern infrastructure. It settles down very unevenly, often sinks catastrophically.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by noir_lord on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:44AM (#20075747)
Those automated machine guns already exist, a Korean company was developing them over a decade ago for the DMZ.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SGR-A1

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by wongarsu on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:09AM (#20075933)
It even comes with full automation, the operator can get up and fetch coffee without worrying about anyone slipping through. How convenient.

I just hope nobody tells Trump these exist.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by noir_lord on Sunday June 02, 2019 @12:14PM (#20076323)
Oh I'm sure he already knows.

...and really how hard would it be to build one of these, the level of CV required is already solved off the shelf, the rest is sensors, servos, a gun to strap to it and programming.

I'd expect a none-trivial percentage of the HN could build one with the resources available.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by wongarsu on Sunday June 02, 2019 @01:36PM (#20076827)
It would be quite a fun project. You could even use machine learning to predict the motion of the target to be most effective even when you reach 1-4 seconds bullet travel time (1 second at the range of the effective range, 4 seconds at maximum range).

Reliably detecting humans sounds hard though. This is a highly adversarial scenario, they will do anything from carrying cardboard in front of them to disguising as wildlife and vegetation. I'm not sure this is even solvable without shooting down anything that moves and is unidentified.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by CydeWeys on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:39AM (#20075365)
This has been a plot of quite a few novels, so I'm struggling to come up with that exact one (if I've even read it). Off the top of my head, Children of Men is similar.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by noir_lord on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:50AM (#20075425)
It definitely wasn't Children of Men, I read so much pulp sci-fi back then it all blurred (except for the stand out stuff like Iain M Banks - I still remember exactly where I was when I read Consider Phlebas - At the caravan park near Pevensey Bay in 1989, book was a birthday present).
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by CydeWeys on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:53AM (#20075453)
Stand on Zanzibar deals with overpopulation too, but that's probably not it either (it's not a central plot point).
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by hedora on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:20AM (#20076008)
The Sheep Look Up was similar, and depressingly prescient.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by ycgeu on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:27AM (#20076045)
Unless they are armed, you can simply shoot at the air and they'll scram.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by CydeWeys on Sunday June 02, 2019 @12:12PM (#20076314)
This "solution" ignores the fallout of said actions. The British lost their highly profitable Indian colony because the citizens at home could not stomach the killings of hundreds of Indians. The average American would not be OK with seeing videos of millions of refugees being mowed down at the border.

And that's ultimately what it would take. When you're dying of dehydration or starving to death, you aren't going to care too much about people shooting into the air.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by ycgeu on Sunday June 02, 2019 @12:25PM (#20076381)
>This "solution" ignores the fallout of said actions. The British lost their highly profitable Indian colony because the citizens at home could not stomach the killings of hundreds of Indians. The average American would not be OK with seeing videos of millions of refugees being mowed down at the border.

When the alternative is living next to them, that perception might change. Time will tell.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by CydeWeys on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:05PM (#20079873)
Most Americans are plenty willing to live next to immigrants. That's not a problem at all. Mmmmmm, tasty food.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by TeMPOraL on Sunday June 02, 2019 @12:06PM (#20076278)
Up until you run out of bullets.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by gingabriska on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:33AM (#20075328)
It's not surprising that people are unable to sympathize with people who they've never seen.

I suggest you travel through India and you'll realize how mistaken you are, sometimes the carbon emission of a village with 100 members is less than a typical American household, specially now when LPG is rolling out even in the remotest and poorest families.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by HillaryBriss on Sunday June 02, 2019 @12:27PM (#20076393)
So, the migration of large numbers of people from a low-energy-per-capita economy to a high-energy-per-capita economy will save lives, but also have the unintended side effect of increasing global temperatures?

If we refuse to reduce our energy expenditures in the US because [stubborn reasons] ... would it be easier to solve global warming by just having everyone in the US migrate to existing more efficient, low-energy-per-capita economies?

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:40AM (#20075375)
For the record; I've travelled in India and parts of Africa. That's not the point. The point is simply biology. If we reduce our population sufficiently (by whatever means), then the effects we have on the global climate may start to wear off. This is just one example of how we are reaching a limit and our species is starting to die off as a result. Given enough such situations our species may eventually reach a sustainable level.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by wongarsu on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:36AM (#20075697)
The problem is that those who emit the most are best equipped against any ill effects. The US (and Europe) are in quite temperate climate. There will be some internal migration to the cooler regions, somewhat higher taxes to pay for sea walls, storm drains and some permamently running pumps, higher insurance premiums for many types of insurance, etc. But all those are minor inconviniences compared to what those that barely have a carbon footprint will experience.

That means whatever nature "does" to kill humans and balance our carbon budget would have to kill 90% of all humans to have enough of an effect. If that's the plan then just nuking the 10% of humanity with the highest carbon emissions would be more efficient and more humane.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by finchisko on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:46AM (#20076146)
I'm living in EU, and have exactly same bad feeling about pollution generated in EU or US having much more worse effect in some other part of the world. I'm trying to advocate for wanting less (stuff, travelling, ...), but it's seems only very few here care.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by tobias3 on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:07AM (#20075523)
I'm more pessimistic. People will come up with something to use up all easily available fossil fuels no matter what population size. E.g. via space tourism, the moon being the new Mount Everest. This can easily be seen by how much more CO2 each US-Amercian emits compared to every other person on earth. So your Thanos solution wouldn't even work short term.

The effect also doesn't wear off until you take the CO2 out of the atomsphere and bury/solidify it, which doesn't happen organically within reasonable (for humans) time frames.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by inapis on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:54AM (#20075458)
Wiping out a 100k population does not have the same effect as wiping out a 10k population which also consumes and emits 10x.

Climate change due to population is not a simple numbers reduction game.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by helloguillecl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:25AM (#20075279)
Quite unfair comment if you consider that probably those affected are the ones emitting far less CO2 per capita, so it would be a non-existent feedback loop.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by Lambdanaut on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:21AM (#20075264)
Actually it will cause the greatest immigration of people we have ever seen.

Putting the current immigration fiasco to shame.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by dependsontheq on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:18AM (#20075250)
Would you write the same thing about Houston or Paris? If not it’s just racist.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by lotsofpulp on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:31AM (#20075313)
This is how all organisms’ population dynamics work. They expand until they meet their boundary conditions.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by mizzao on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:49AM (#20075415)
In humans case, we may actually be making our boundaries smaller and smaller by changing the planet.

Would it be a tragedy if humans went extinct?

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:59AM (#20075480)
"Would it be a tragedy if humans went extinct?" - The planet doesn't care. The only species that cares is humans. Tragedy? Not really. The universe will move on. We are quite insignificant as-is.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by TeMPOraL on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:45AM (#20075750)
The defining charteristic of humanity is that we refuse to accept natural population dynamics and don't let ourselves be governed by them.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by lotsofpulp on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:55AM (#20076200)
Humans have figured out some neat tricks to create hospitable boundary conditions where there were non, e.g. moving water, heat, and themselves around, but so have other organisms. But by definition, they are all subject to “natural population dynamics”, such as the sun going supernova, an asteroid hitting the earth, earth’s temperature rising a few degrees.

Also, I would bet long term survival success (very long term) under various environmental changes to organisms such as water bears over humans.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tardigrade

Unless we figure out cheap space travel and water production in the next few hundred years.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by imtringued on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:56AM (#20076206)
In this case it's the opposite. We are sawing off the branch we are sitting on. It's not that we are expanding, we are shrinking the boundary conditions!
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by tinus_hn on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:39AM (#20075371)
Houston and Paris are not races.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by inflatableDodo on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:48AM (#20075414)
Now, this is what I generally qualify as the "that's not racist, it's bigoted" pedant's defense.

And it really doesn't carry quite as much weight as people apparently think it does.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by tinus_hn on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:00AM (#20075484)
If you think that is the answer, call it bigoted instead of playing the race card.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by inflatableDodo on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:20AM (#20075609)
I generally do use the word bigot rather than racist. I know very few people who are only racist and not bigoted in other ways, so it tends to be more accurate. It also gives much less wiggle room and appears to cut into people's ego far more.

As another observation, I have yet to meet anyone who uses the phrase 'playing the race card', that has a considered opinion on that subject, or indeed many others. It is indicative of a thought process constructed almost entirely from clichés.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:57AM (#20076213)
Well, thank you for putting people in boxes.

One can have a considered opinion and still think that playing the "race card" is despicable.

Try not to be so single-minded.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by inflatableDodo on Sunday June 02, 2019 @12:08PM (#20076291)
I think you missed the nuance. I was saying that I find that people who use that term do not generally have considered opinions. As for putting people in boxes, I thought you were the one advocating that. Wooden ones, specifically.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:21AM (#20075261)
Why not? I just said "sufficient populated areas". That does not mean only India. Nothing racist about it. I mean, globally speaking, wiping out New York City and all the people in it would also provide a benefit.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by inflatableDodo on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:58AM (#20075478)
I think you have made your position completely clear. You first please.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:11AM (#20075549)
Me first what? I don't get what you are saying / you don't make any sense to me. I'm glad I have apparently made my point clear. But what is yours??

And please don't pull that bogus racist card again. Race has got nothing to do with any of my comments.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by inflatableDodo on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:29AM (#20075663)
I never said it did. However for my views on people using the term 'race card' please see my replies to tinus_hn.

Now this isn't personal to you specifically, however in regard to your query, Me first what?, I have long thought that people who advocate the benefits of depopulation by mass die-off, should generally lead by example.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:38AM (#20075711)
I probably will - given age and living habits. But that aside; are you saying that we should try and sustain inbounded population growth on this tiny globe of ours? And if so, why/how?
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by inflatableDodo on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:59AM (#20075849)
From a purely practical standpoint, I don't think a die-off will help very much. Say we had a 85% die off, we would be back to around the population level of 1800, the time that Malthus published his prophecy. And along the way we would have had the most collossal wars imaginable and would be ekeing out a living on a much reduced habitable area.

Basically, although it is an unpopular vision these days, I suspect that for the amount of effort involved in having a mass die-off, we could stabilise the population somewhat and start building floating cities and space habitats. People regard this kind of thing as unrealistic, but I think it will rapidly become realistic should we even halt population growth temporarily through environmental disaster and it would be preferable to start doing it before that signal to action.

To sit on our hands and hope for our own actions to kill us off in order to save some remainder is the most fatalistic and least imaginative approach going. We might as well be deer.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:03AM (#20075884)
"We might as well be deer" - and what tells you that in the grand, global, universe-scale sense, we are not?

In my eyes, we very much are.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by inflatableDodo on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:14AM (#20075968)
>what tells you that in the grand, global, universe-scale sense, we are not?

If we were deer, then Malthus would have been right by now. We are fairly uniquely placed as a species to be able to avoid being this dumb.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:42AM (#20076116)
I'm sorry, but I just have to do this.

Even with Trump as president?

He takes "dumb" to a whole new level!

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by inflatableDodo on Sunday June 02, 2019 @12:00PM (#20076246)
Look at some of the people funding him and ask yourself what their motivation is. It maybe isn't that dumb, at least if your motivation is to destroy confidence in democracy as a system and eventually balkanise the US so it can be openly ruled by princelings. He is pretty good for that.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by galago on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:34AM (#20075335)
If a 'die-off' happens at large scale within a country that has nuclear weapons, everyone on the planet could be involved. For example, they could make a unilateral decision to detonate nuclear bombs on the surface of the earth to throw up particulates and cool things down. That would 'suck' for everyone if it didn't work as expected.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by pedrocr on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:42AM (#20075383)
Have you tried raise VAT and kill the poor?

https://youtu.be/owI7DOeO_yg

Except this is a comedy sketch. Considering massive human die-offs as a solution to the climate crisis is not just inhumane it's also very unlikely to work without massive extra consequences from war and other disasters.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by vbezhenar on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:20AM (#20075259)
Probably those people would install more air-conditioners and that would increase energy needs.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by lotsofpulp on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:32AM (#20075324)
Assuming they can afford the air conditioners and electricity and electric grid.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by vbezhenar on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:40AM (#20075372)
Affording air conditioner probably the same like affording warm house in cold climate.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by TheCoelacanth on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:44AM (#20076131)
A median Indian makes barely over $50/month[1]. Electricity is only slightly cheaper than the US[2]. Much of the country couldn't afford AC even if it were their only living expense.

[1] https://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/ind...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_pricing#Price_Comp...

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by adrianN on Sunday June 02, 2019 @09:57AM (#20075472)
I think you underestimate the poverty of the average Indian.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:13AM (#20075964)
Affording that would likely equate several years of income to the average poor Indian. If even obtainable in a lifetime.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by vbezhenar on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:44AM (#20076132)
Air conditioner is like few hundred dollars. Are homes in India that cheap? Even cheapest homes in my countries will cost thousands of dollars. If someone can buy it, he can buy air conditioner.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:58AM (#20076225)
You underestimate the depth of poverty for some people. When you are living under a trash-heap as your home, a hundred dollars is a fortune fit for a king.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by akashakya on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:15AM (#20075577)
By that logic anything which kills mass population is "not so bad". Why not just bomb cities. Infact if you read it as a response to "world wars", though not intended, that way of thinking justify that.
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:29AM (#20075659)
It depends on your view of the world I guess. In my view, humans are not special. We have no inherent right to live on this planet compared to other animals. Why should we not die off and let other creatures live? Only selfishness (and our cognitive ability to have it), enables; I want to live. Humans are not special (except for currently being at the top of the food-chain). We have reached our biological population limit. And it needs to go down. And even if it goes to zero, the universe won't care. We are just another species and we are about to go extinct, like so many before us. Unless drastic measures are taken. But the only ones who will care are still us, the humans. Maybe we just shouldn't, and die out and let some other, better suited, organism take over. Or none at all. In the end it doesn't actually matter...
Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by ss248 on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:56AM (#20075824)
Humans are actually special. We are smarter than any other animal on earth and have culture. Human brain is the most complex structure in the known universe, so even on that scale we are pretty special.

And it simply makes no sense to just throw away millions of years of evolution. Your nihilistic worldview is very naive.

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by jjuhl on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:10AM (#20075941)
Nihilistic it may be. But please don't equate nihilism and nativity.

"And it simply makes no sense to just throw away millions of years of evolution" - Why not?

Re:India heatwave temperatures pass 50 Celsius by ss248 on Sunday June 02, 2019 @11:28AM (#20076050)
To put it bluntly, because the road constant progress and improvement can potentially unveil the meaning of existence of the universe. Nihilism is naive by definition, just because you don't know the meaning, doesn't mean that there is no meaning at all.