News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:ISPs in AU and NZ start censoring the internet without le... by huntie on Saturday March 23, 2019 @08:55PM (#19473337)
First, I agree that the US has an incarceration problem. We're certainly not perfect, and I think much of the problem is due to the US's drug problem. Regardless, comparing incarceration to slavery is disingenuous as slavery requires no wrongdoing whereas incarceration should require wrongdoing.

As for my comparison of disallowing hate speech to slavery, it is a very valid comparison. The two are morally reprehensible for similar reasons; one is slavery of the body, the other is slavery of the mind. History has shown time and again that what is en vogue today may be hate speech tomorrow.

Re:ISPs in AU and NZ start censoring the internet without le... by marcus_holmes on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:17PM (#19473735)
what about "collective" cultures that don't prize individualism? If you are discouraged from saying something because it will cause social disharmony within your community, is that as morally wrong as slavery?

I think not.

I think capturing someone from their home, their country, their loved ones, transporting them across an ocean, beating them, making them work for the rest of their lives without pay, while starving them, raping them, and imprisoning them, is a long, long, long way more morally wrong than not letting idiots spout whatever crappy opinion happens to wander across what passes for their mind, regardless of what damage it causes.

Re:ISPs in AU and NZ start censoring the internet without le... by Nasrudith on Sunday March 24, 2019 @01:14AM (#19474494)
To be frank 'collective' cultures seems to be a cop-out trope to excuse authoritarianism as 'just part of their culture' mixed with exoticism. It would be like excusing warlords as 'just a part of the culture' when everyone who isn't a part of his army wants him dead but is too afraid to take action and is essentially complicity in manufactured consent.

A true collective culture would have no need for laws as cudgels for such matters because doing something 'selfish' would already make them an outcast surely as becoming an outspoken NAMBLA supporter.

Re:ISPs in AU and NZ start censoring the internet without le... by marcus_holmes on Monday March 25, 2019 @03:18AM (#19480788)
Having lived and worked in a collective culture, no it's not a cop-out. They literally value harmony over truth. It's very hard for a western mind to understand (as I have discovered).
Re:ISPs in AU and NZ start censoring the internet without le... by seventhtiger on Sunday March 24, 2019 @02:47AM (#19474840)
Isn't the logical conclusion to your argument anarchy? Isn't democracy just a populist brand of authoritarianism?

The utility of all laws and enforcement in general can't be used to argue against a specific law.

Re:ISPs in AU and NZ start censoring the internet without le... by huntie on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:27PM (#19473782)
"I think capturing..."

This is a very American-centric view of slavery. Most cultures have participated in slavery at some point in history without the extraneous parts. Even if you treat your slave as family, the slavery is still immoral.

Similarly, your views on free speech are very narrow-minded. Many people have been murdered by oppressive governments for speaking out against injustice. Were they "idiots spout[ing] whatever crappy opinion happens to wander across what passes for their mind"?

If you are discouraged from saying something for _any_ reason, this is slavery of the mind. As for collective cultures, I don't think I know enough to effectively comment. I will note that many cultures that were okay at one time are now viewed with disgust as primitive, including your depiction of slavery in the Americas.

Re:ISPs in AU and NZ start censoring the internet without le... by rbg246 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:08PM (#19473407)
I don't see any problem with a government who is freely elected enacting laws that disallow hate speech.

To assist with balancing these rights and restrictions there is an independent judiciary and court system that moderates these laws and works out whether they have gone too far.

Re:ISPs in AU and NZ start censoring the internet without le... by int_19h on Sunday March 24, 2019 @12:10AM (#19474250)
So long as you can ensure that discussing what is and isn't hate speech is never classified as hate speech itself.
Re:ISPs in AU and NZ start censoring the internet without le... by ekianjo on Saturday March 23, 2019 @08:45PM (#19473281)
Note that in the US the prison population has exploded since the mental institutions were closed (i.e. there was a transfer of people with mental problems to prisons) which explains also why you have this increased percentage compared to other countries.