News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Newfound fossils in China highlight a dizzying diversity ... by dTal on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:03PM (#19470971)
All of the Cambrian biodiversity was underwater, with nothing larger than bacteria on land. Would you consider it a good thing if the world suddenly flooded?

(In case the point isn't clear: even if we exactly reverted to Cambrian conditions, that would be Bad for humans (there were no humans in the Cambrian) - but that wouldn't happen anyway, what would actually happen is everything would die from the sudden shock.)

Re:Newfound fossils in China highlight a dizzying diversity ... by maxxxxx on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:34AM (#19470599)
I hope you aren't just trying to be cute but here is what I think:

They are a disaster because we have found some equilibrium with the current state. When temperatures change there will probably have to be mass migrations of people from areas that became inhabitable to places that became habitable. I believe in the long run we'll be fine but in the short run you will see a lot of conflict and war to fight for resources. This won't be pleasant.

Re:Newfound fossils in China highlight a dizzying diversity ... by ams6110 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @04:28PM (#19472186)
> you will see a lot of conflict and war to fight for resources. This won't be pleasant.

So in other words, like all of human history?

Re:Newfound fossils in China highlight a dizzying diversity ... by brazzledazzle on Saturday March 23, 2019 @11:20AM (#19470805)
They’re a disaster when you consider the human suffering and impact on the biodiversity of the species currently living. It doesn’t matter if biodiversity ends up great over the next millennia if large portions (or all) of humanity die off and suffer during an adjustment period. People are concerned about the earth and environment but they’re also worried about humans because they’re humans too.

You’ve built a straw man and can’t understand why it burns so brightly.

Re:Newfound fossils in China highlight a dizzying diversity ... by astazangasta on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:00PM (#19470964)
Go look up the PT or KT extinction events. The PT was particularly traumatic and involved significant runaway warming, including possibly the firing of the "clathrate gun".

In general the point is, dramatic changes in the climate may be good for future evolved life forms, but they will suck for existing ones.

Re:Newfound fossils in China highlight a dizzying diversity ... by dTal on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:04PM (#19470975)
Did you mean to say "clathrate gun"?
Re:Newfound fossils in China highlight a dizzying diversity ... by astazangasta on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:14PM (#19471023)
Yes, a thousand curses on the creators of autocorrect.
Re:Newfound fossils in China highlight a dizzying diversity ... by woodandsteel on Saturday March 23, 2019 @06:29PM (#19472687)
One reason it is bad is that the temperature rise is happening at least two orders of magnitude faster than in the past, so evolution can't keep up.

Another is that maybe a billion people live in areas that would become uninhabitable.