News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by sctb on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:47PM (#18554365)
We already asked you to stop posting generic ideological rants. Could you please do that?

We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18553560 and marked it off-topic.

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:07PM (#18553952)
> But yet when the very idea of alimony is "I'm a lesser woman because I married",

That's not the idea of alimony.

The idea of alimony is closer to “I sacrificed my future income for my husband's by the division of domestic vs. external work in marriage”.

> Say.. How many men get alimony?

A small but growing number, largely because of slow erosion of persistent patriarchal gender roles which manifest in a number of ways.

(1) Men are still more likely to support their wives and have their career advancement and future income potential dominate in marriage than vice versa, making them less likely to be eligible for alimony,

(2) Men are less likely to seek alimony when they are eligible,

(3) Men are less likely to resist alimony demands in divorce,

(4) There's bias in judging where judges are more likely to view men as capable of independent self-support and less deserving of alimony in objectively similar conditions.

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by petra on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:43PM (#18554329)
>> persistent patriarchal gender roles which manifest in a number of ways:

>> men .. have their career advancement and future income potential dominate in marriage

Is it really a gender role ? or, a genetic adaptation - with females being attracted to more successful men, because it helps give their children helpful resources ?

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:58PM (#18554485)
> Is it really a gender role ?

Yes, it is really a gender role.

> or, a genetic adaptation - with females being attracted to more successful men, because it helps give their children helpful resources ?

You are presenting a false dilemma; that it may be, in whole or in part, a product of genetic adaptation does not impact whether or not is a gender role.

The debate you seem to want to have is over whether gender roles are pure social constructs or not, which may be an interesting debate but isn't actually all that germane here. The gender role in question exists and contributes to the effect under discussion and is manifestly changing, though slower than some people might prefer.

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by crankylinuxuser on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:25PM (#18554141)
> The idea of alimony is closer to “I sacrificed my future income for my husband's by the division of domestic vs. external work in marriage”.

I'd argue that's even worse, as it encourages economic classes to 'marry amongst oneselves; don't relate with lesser people's

And that very statement also packs in the idea the woman is some married domestic servant. And increasingly that is not true. My wife and I share the work. Equally. We both work. Right now I make more, but before this job, she made more. And now, on my extra salary, she's attending Harvard. Soon enough, she'll make more than I.

And the sooner these gender roles are busted thoroughly for both men and women, the better we all will do.

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:38PM (#18554270)
> I'd argue that's even worse, as it encourages economic classes to 'marry amongst oneselves; don't relate with lesser people's

Well, no, if you are interested in minimizing alimony, it encourages working to maximize your partners income and income potential during marriage (in addition to working to avoid divorce.)

> And that very statement also packs in the idea the woman is some married domestic servant.

No, it implies that marriage often involves a division of responsibility and/or a trade-offs where one person's income earning potential is sacrificed for the others; subordination (master/servant) rather than co-equal status is irrelevant.

> And increasingly that is not true.

Yes, it's less true over time that wives are sacrificing more income potential in marriage in favor of their husbands, as the old traditional division of marital roles becomes less absolutely dominant.

And increasingly fewer women and more men get spousal support, which reflects that.

> My wife and I share the work. Equally. We both work. Right now I make more, but before this job, she made more. And now, on my extra salary, she's attending Harvard. Soon enough, she'll make more than I.

Good for you. I'm not sure what you think this has to do with anything, since we aren't discussing who should or shouldn't get spousal support in your hypothetical divorce.

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by danso on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:04PM (#18553924)
There are likely feminists who would be OK with the alimony pendulum swinging the other way as a result of gender parity in salaries and careers.
Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by jvp on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:01PM (#18553882)
Kevin Federline
Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by cortesoft on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:30PM (#18554188)
If the wife makes more money, absolutely.
Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by dgzl on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:23PM (#18554120)
I'm all for equal rights 100%, but a lot of women conveniently forget about the bonus benefits society gives them just for being women, and they don't seem keen in giving it up/transferring to men when the time comes.

As examples... holding the door open for women. The idea of "ladies first". The custom of men being required to message first on dating services. Men paying for dinner/etc.

I don't know about the rest of you, but I don't see women jumping to embrace this kind of equality.

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by BorgHunter on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:34PM (#18554229)
> holding the door open for women

I hold the door open for everyone. Male, female, and other. This is common courtesy.

> The idea of "ladies first".

I've never really encountered this.

> The custom of men being required to message first on dating services.

My wife messaged me first when we met on OkCupid.

> Men paying for dinner

Similarly, on our first date my wife offered to do half/half, but I insisted on paying largely because she was still a college student at that point, and I was not.

> I don't know about the rest of you, but I don't see women jumping to embrace this kind of equality.

Well, one of us is the more rare case. I'm not sure which one.

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by rootusrootus on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:52PM (#18554422)
Those are pretty weak examples. There are some legitimate gripes you could have brought up, IMO. Things like the way a man can get treated (ostracized or worse) when he shows up at a playground with his young daughter. Or the way many women react in a situation when it's just the two of you that implies she is really afraid of you. It makes me pretty uncomfortable to be in those situations but nobody really cares. That's a legit gripe. At the same time, men do basically run the world at this point, even if individually many of us are not in any kind of powerful role.
Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by dgzl on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @02:06PM (#18554582)
I agree, I was just trying to pick quick examples.

Last year I was in line trying to get into a college dance club, and a group of girls in front of me started screaming, one saying "I lost my phone! Someone stole my phone!" They turned and made face at me and started accusing me of theft. My friends were already in and I was alone in line, clearly minding my own business to anyone paying attention. But once they started screaming I had to defend myself by basically yelling at them that they were being stupid and to leave me alone. They started makinga big scene and people all around were getting interested. Just a bit later and the girl just pathetically says "oh I found it" and walks away with her phone, clearly unconcerned with the potential fallout against me.

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by crankylinuxuser on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:39PM (#18554280)
> I don't know about the rest of you, but I don't see women jumping to embrace this kind of equality.

There's a few. You see them, by the way they do head forward in male-dominated careers that don't have prestige. Think: manual labor, professional manual labor (framers, steamfitters, plumbers, electricians, etc), military combat, and more. And there are a few who speak of equality (not equity).

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by cortesoft on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:36PM (#18554245)
I find a good majority of people hold the door open for everyone. The rule is usually, the first person to the door holds it open for the people behind. That certainly crosses gender lines.

I think most feminists don't think men should pay for dinner each time on a date, and don't think "ladies first" is a rule we should keep.

I don't know what you mean by "I don't see women jumping to embrace this kind of equality". Do you mean you don't see women protesting trying to get these equalities? That is incredibly disingenuous to claim that women not fighting for these equalities means they think they should persist. They don't fight for those equalities because those aren't the ones they need to fight for. They need to fight for the ones that are holding them back. Those other ones can follow.

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by dgzl on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @02:11PM (#18554631)
I see many people, myself included, protesting for genuine equality. The only thing disingenuous I see is people thinking you can obtain both equality and equity at the same time.

Bad examples aside, women get a "leg up" in a lot of ways, and men do too. If we want equally, we either need to be inclusive so that everyone gets the same leg up, or we need to compensate with different kinds of legs.

Re:Did a Rave Review Really Shut Down Portland Burger Bar St... by tomhoward on Thursday November 29, 2018 @04:26AM (#18559040)
Plenty of women are jumping to embrace this kind of equality. It's not always easy due to established behavioural tendencies, but I know of plenty of women who are determined to embrace equality on things like door-opening and dating.