One who pays close attention—who am I kidding, even passing attention—to Trump's entire life story shows a consistent pattern of utter selfishness and narcissism, unwillingness to take any responsibility for the consequences of his actions, and a complete willingness to sacrifice anything and cause any manner of harm in order to further his person desires.
Trying to compare Trump to other presidents isn't useful
> Its not led to nuclear war precisely because there exists a command authority and leadership depth in the US (and Russia) that has worked well enough.
So far. Not leading to the end of the world does not mean a system is good or has sufficient safety just that it hasn't failed in the time period
> Try not to confuse political rhetoric with a lack of self-awareness when judging the current President.
There is no need for pathologizing or political rhetoric
We know from Woodwards book and plenty of other sources, not from political opponents but people inside the administration exactly how crazy things are
I too have paid closer attention to the current president’s remarks, and I see so evidence of self-awareness and self-control. I see bullying pretending to be strength. I see habitual self-aggrandizing lies. I see the worst kind of bullshitter: one that believes his own bullshit.
https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/we-have-enough-checks-...
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-mecklin-nuclear-commentar...
The president can’t “spin a globe” and order a strike and it be legally a valid order; there is a lot more to it than that.
The second link explicitly says:
"""The president holds the constitutional position of commander in chief and is obligated to protect the United States from foreign threats. The Constitution does grant to Congress the power to declare war, but it is unclear whether a law that significantly constrained the president’s nuclear command authority — particularly when the United States or it allies are under attack or in imminent danger of attack — would be constitutional. """
Instead, I'll point you to this: https://www.npr.org/2017/10/03/555266383/why-president-trump...
In this case, if the President spins the globe and orders a strike and his Cabinet members tell him "uh, no," then the law doesn't matter. The strike does not happen.
This problem is normally averted by displaying leadership and earning loyalty so that your subordinates will obey you when the time comes. Failing that, you can fire people until you get to someone who will obey (e.g. the Saturday Night Massacre), but of course that only works if there is such a person to be had.
Not really. Even the President cannot issue unlawful orders; if they do, they should not be followed. If someone follows an unlawful order, they are still guilty of the crime, they cannot use the defense “just following orders”. That was the Nazi defense, and it did not stand at Nurenberg.
Back to the US military, here’s the oath taken by those who serve
“I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; and that I will obey the orders of the President of the United States and the orders of the officers appointed over me, according to regulations and the Uniform Code of Military Justice “
The sec of defense has to confirm the presidents identity but not the wisdom of the order
Radiolab did a story on this and a former secretary of state confirmed it
https://www.wnycstudios.org/story/nukes
The principle for the army to not obey unlawful orders is the only legal way to stop a president from launching nukes. And that is very much a grey area (as to what is an unlawful order).
Nixon's aides made sure he wouldn't launch nukes when he was unstable but did so in an illegal manner