Completely agree.
I remember these couple of guys from Stanford working on this project called Backrub. I think it was for search or something.
I can't think of anything more boring or repetitive than search, and making money is definitely not in the cards there.
Wonder how many investors they had to pitch before they gave up and went back to school.
Suckers.
Not every startup has the potential to be the next Google, that's just a fact of life.
My point, though, is that the list of people genuinely qualified to make those assessments is extraordinarily short, and even they get it wrong sometimes. The spectrum between stupid and crazy enough to work is an especially muddy one. It's easy to snipe at people, but in the end someone with their nuts on the line pushing a crazy idea has, at least, stepped up.
So if such a person wants to pitch a co-founder and hopefully make some magic happen, I'm not of the mind to criticize. No one has to listen to them, or join them, but let 'em pitch.
At some point a company just gets large enough to buy or edge out the competition.