> The downvoters are ignorant as usual because they have nothing else to say
> I have contacted my MEP
I didn’t downvote you, but I understand why others may have. You claim the EU isn’t a democracy and then mention reaching out to your MEP. Additionally, calling out those who disagree with you as “ignorant as usual” may be seen by some, myself included, as a premature conclusion.
2) The EU is a complex organization and not just the democratically elected EU parliament.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_to_the_European_Parl...
https://europa.eu/european-union/about-eu/institutions-bodie...
If the EU is a democracy or not can be very well debated and IMO it is not a democracy.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy
https://diem25.org/why-europes-treaties-are-failing-its-citi...
3) Quote from https://juliareda.eu/eu-copyright-reform/ :
"EU member state governments approved the plans (while suggesting some changes) in the Council. Only the Parliament can stop them now."
So other EU member states decide the copyright laws for my EU member state (Belgium).
You're defining "democracy" as "direct democracy," which is inconsistent with the common use of the former.
I mention the reasons why the EU might not be a democracy and why the decisions regarding the new copyright laws are not very democratic.
Even if the people had a choice (direct democracy) which they have not, the people would need to know about what is at stake by being honestly and completely and actively informed by EU and the mainstream media which they are not.
It is contradictory or undemocratic to do both:
- Say the EU is a democracy because the representatives in the EU parliament have been elected to make the decisions at their own will.
- Say that people (opponents) should get involved to pressure or to beg the representatives to enforce the preferences of the loud opponents (probably a minority).
That most Europeans have little idea what's going on is a reflection of the almost complete absence of media coverage of the issue. How would you expect them to know in that situation?
The EU is not. https://europa.eu/european-union/about-eu/institutions-bodie...
One has to wonder if the combination of lack of voting by the people (for whatever reasons) and lack of knowledge of the people should be called a democracy.
I am not alone.
https://diem25.org/why-europes-treaties-are-failing-its-citi...
Even if the Civil Service or Council of Europe propose legislation it still requires vote by the relevant parliament to be adopted, sometimes the European Council (heads of member states) vote too.
You could make the same criticism of any representative democracy: UK, US, all the way down to town council elections. So what now? Referenda for every single proposed law and by-law? Brexit tells me that might not be considered democratic progress.
So where does that leave democracy? Non-existent globally?
There's a completely different discussion and points on either side about voter engagement and disenfranchisement.
An EU member state is a representative democracy.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Representative_democracy
The EU is not.
The non-democratic nature goes beyond legislation and affects the economy and poverty and austerity and taxes of members of the Eurozone who have given up their economic and thus political and thus democratic and cultural sovereignty.
Granted, the decision to remain in the Eurozone is a national democratic decision.
The situation of Greece shows that interests of private companies and states like Germany have priority over the poor members of the Eurozone and EU and IMO over good ethics and the common good.
Regarding Italy:
http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=39454
http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=39557
http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=39549
It is clear that EU member states are still competing against each other and that the EU is not a common democratic state but an organization where an EU elite and elites of competing members states and lobbyists fight for their ideological and economic and political interests.