[dead]
Re:A Wikipedia editor's long-running campaign
by _vertigo on Saturday May 19, 2018 @04:56PM
(#17109695)
Of course, you can't exactly claim Vox isn't a legitimate news source without citing some sources either.
(Whether or not Vox is "legitimate" or not is beside the point here, the point is it's hypocritical of you to call someone's sources into question without providing any yourself.)
Re:A Wikipedia editor's long-running campaign
by Confiks on Saturday May 19, 2018 @04:59PM
(#17109711)
Your post is a clear example of an ad hominem and whataboutism [1], an invalid argument, where you cite the usage of a link to Vox to completely dismiss the parent as untrustworthy.
There's an object-level point that can be made about referencing an even more partisan source like Rationalwiki as a response in this particular thread, but the more interesting meta-level observation is that the whole Wikipedia sourcing/attribution mechanism is clearly inadequate for an age where even a fairly casual discussion in HN comments can't be completed without relying on sources that one of the two parties to the debate will consider clearly inadmissible (Vox and Rationalwiki for one side, and maybe Craig Murray and Sputnik for the other).