News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by scarmig on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:31PM (#14628323)
"We all know"

Social security is about as far from a Ponzi scheme as you can get. That don't mean state pensions never have problems, but in principle you can always balance expenditures with revenue.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by mixedCase on Sunday June 25, 2017 @01:28AM (#14628775)
If the scheme completely falls down without new investors, and the solution to having fewer investors than expected is to reduce the payout, I don't see how it isn't just a Ponzi scheme with extra steps.

As an anecdote, I've tried to search opinions disagreeing with me, looking for an explanation on how SS isn't a Ponzi scheme; but the all the arguments I've found boil down to "it has worked so far", "it is well-intentioned" and "people investing into it are not being intentionally misled".

Without having most people lose money on their investment (by dying earlier than the projected age when calculating pension), I fail to see how it can work out as anything else than a pyramid scheme.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by scarmig on Thursday June 29, 2017 @03:37PM (#14666222)
Ponzi schemes, by definition, collapse at the end: each stage of "investors" have to be exponentially larger than the previous, and there's only so many people that can be involved before it becomes impossible to reproduce the next stage. The majority of participants get nothing, for that reason.

State pensions don't work like this. Even in disadvantageous demographic situations, the majority of people get something comparable to what they put in. Even in the most aged populations you don't go from X to 0; you go from X to (1 - c)X, where c is relatively small; that is, much closer to 0 than to 1.

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by tanilama on Sunday June 25, 2017 @06:43AM (#14629477)
Reform? People won't vote to make them poorer. So, either keep the Ponzi scheme going or democracy must go, since it will be some strongman stand up and stop paying pensioners that much.

And it is not democracy anymore, but rather a system that exploit the few to keep itself from dying. Either way, the society will be a very different one by then, very different indeed

Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by hkmurakami on Saturday June 24, 2017 @11:04PM (#14628406)
The elderly voting block dominates Japanese votes. Pension reform will never happen because the ones who would get the immediate short end of the stick will never vote to hurt themselves right now, even if it meant helping out their children in the long run.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by netheril96 on Saturday June 24, 2017 @10:48PM (#14628374)
Reform how? When there are no young people capable of doing actual work, wealth redistribution doesn't matter as there is no wealth.
Re:Japan, Short on Babies, Reaches a Worrisome Milestone by nine_k on Sunday June 25, 2017 @03:08AM (#14628979)
People can start producing more wealth per worker. Despite shrinking workforce, Japan's GDP per capita keeps growing since 2009 (the world crisis made a large dent in the chart in 2008-09).