News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Atom 1.18 released by Guillaume86 on Friday June 16, 2017 @10:25AM (#14569258)
If you never enjoyed the experience of a lightweight editor or was never bothered by the sluggishness of heavy weight IDEs, fine but don't blame any praise you don't understand on astroturfing.

I use both VS and VSCode and I prefer using VSCode by far.

Re:Atom 1.18 released by endorphone on Friday June 16, 2017 @10:46AM (#14569459)
If you never enjoyed the experience of a lightweight editor or was never bothered by the sluggishness of heavy weight IDEs

Neither Atom or VS Code are lightweight. Both feel absolutely glacial compared to those other IDEs (including even IDEA that is atop Java). This mythology that they're "light" isn't remotely founded in reality.

Regarding astroturfing, your claim is exactly the sort of claim that seems suspicious. If Visual Studio or IDEA is scary (if I was setting my son up with something simple to play around with web development), sure use something superficially simpler, but the claims of lightness are outrageously detached from reality.

Another comment mentioned a negative association with Microsoft, and I'm going to say it's that association that yields the pseudo-astroturfing -- lots of developers who threw their hat into the Microsoft stack, and now that they have something that is open source-y and cross platform, they advocate it for legitimacy. It's an option, sure, but the over the top gushing for another Electron-based editor is surreal.

Re:Atom 1.18 released by Tarean on Friday June 16, 2017 @10:35AM (#14569367)
I use Intellij for java and vim for most other languages. I started using VS Code more often recently because it is really easy to set up ide like tooling for smaller languages in it. Vim usually involves manually configuring plugins and possibly setting up environment variables.

Emacs probably also could fill this niche but whenever I try I run into things like term mode that clash with evil in horrendous ways.

Re:Atom 1.18 released by allover on Friday June 16, 2017 @10:28AM (#14569298)
Seems fairly obvious to me why VS Code would be popular with web devs like myself. It has a built in JS debugger and lots of web-related stuff works out of the box (TypeScript, JSX etc). Also the fact it is built in JS means it's easy to extend in JS, so the plugin community is already very healthy. The Vim mode is pretty damn good too (first editor to tempt me away from Vim since I learnt Vim).

I don't think there's any astroturfing/fishiness at all. If anything the opposite, they've had to overcome the negative association with MS, and to some small degree Electron. They seem to have done that by 'making a good thing', that everyone who tries is somewhat impressed with.

You mention Visual Studio and IntelliJ. Two obvious downsides with those - former is only on Windows, the other is relatively expensive. I tried IntelliJ Webstorm once, seemed good but I never really got a good enough feel for it before my trial ran out, so never tried again shrug.

Re:Atom 1.18 released by addicted on Friday June 16, 2017 @10:54AM (#14569523)
I have Visual Studio installed, but still use VS Code often.

They serve different purposes, and VS Code is much nicer for web style development than Visual Studio is, which feels far too heavy.

And though VS 2017 has improved this, Visual Studio is a pain to use for non proj/sln based projects.

I am primarily a VIM user, but there are many times where the GUI niceness of VS Code, combined with it's relative light weight makes it a good option.