News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Google Bug Bounty – The $5k Error Page by dsacco on Thursday May 18, 2017 @07:31PM (#14371913)
I wish I could flag this.

There's invariably one comment like this on bug bounty stories here. One comment that isn't happy with the bug bounty result even when the researcher is and goes off the rails with a weird anti-large company bias and some conspiracy.

This has absolutely nothing to do with your Nexus RMA story, or your cloud SLA story from downthread, or whatever other agenda you have against these large companies.

Do you have any concept of it's like to run a bug bounty at Google's size? Have you ever been involved in managing one? Have you ever participated in one? Can you qualify any of your opinion with something aside from these irrelevant grievances you're throwing out?

You're not contributing to the discussion at all, you're just hijacking the thread so you can perpetuate your soapbox. Human beings make mistakes and bug bounties are an easy place to drop the ball. No one is trying to cheat security researchers out of their rewards.

Re:Google Bug Bounty – The $5k Error Page by Buge on Thursday May 18, 2017 @10:57PM (#14372729)
Some companies do worse than attempt to cheat people out of rewards: they threaten to sue them. But Google doesn't do that.
Re:Google Bug Bounty – The $5k Error Page by foota on Thursday May 18, 2017 @07:07PM (#14371796)
I find it much more likely that they just dropped the ball on paying them, rather than maliciously trying to deny them a bounty.
Re:Google Bug Bounty – The $5k Error Page by mickrussom on Thursday May 18, 2017 @07:19PM (#14371860)
Try arguing with them about an SLA violation they had with their cloud infrastructure. The game is setup where they can chisel and have these guffaw and aw garsh moments but every adword and every billable second on their cloud will get paid hell or high water.
Re:Google Bug Bounty – The $5k Error Page by dsacco on Thursday May 18, 2017 @07:26PM (#14371884)
Did you seriously come to hijack a story about a Google bug bounty so you could complain about an irrelevant issue?
Re:Google Bug Bounty – The $5k Error Page by lucb1e on Friday May 19, 2017 @01:08AM (#14373167)
If I'm being completely fair, how often does HN as a whole discuss related topics or cases in the comment thread? The best example is probably that people kept mentioning Reader shutting down whenever they launched something new, a la "not going to use this, see what they did to Reader".

Not sure it's entirely the same as this case, but hijacking threads with "remember when this happened?" is not that unique.

Re:Google Bug Bounty – The $5k Error Page by richforrester on Thursday May 18, 2017 @07:09PM (#14371805)
Sounds like everyone got what they wanted.

Also sounds like you were dealing with humans, who (before escalating) followed company protocols.

Also seems not too far-fetched that those protocols are in place to weed out the whatever% that make bogus claims.

All in all, nothing I'd call "truly sad", "evil" and whatnot. Just big businesses being big businesses.

Re:Google Bug Bounty – The $5k Error Page by afpx on Thursday May 18, 2017 @07:21PM (#14371864)
Curious why you have such high tolerance for this type of behavior, since it appears that you don't actually approve of it.
Re:Google Bug Bounty – The $5k Error Page by dsacco on Thursday May 18, 2017 @07:28PM (#14371897)
I can't speak for the parent, but I have a tolerance for it because I've actually managed bug bounty programs; I also know Google receives on the order of 100,000 bug bounty reports annually, while a full order of magnitude less are actually valid.
Re:Google Bug Bounty – The $5k Error Page by richforrester on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:45PM (#14372879)
Similar. Experience tought me that having patience for bad situations leads to more understanding and easier solving of issues.

The fact is that the more people are involved in a process, the slower the cogs turn.

Having patience is more of a defense mechanism than it is anything else. It has served me well and made life easier!