[dead]
Knowing a little about the people who make Signal, and their principles (particularly Moxie Marlinspike), it would surprise me nigh unto death were they to compromise its security in any way.
Of course there's a backdoor for targeted surveillance - no phones stand up to that, especially if you can devote a few man-hours for hands-on manipulation of the device. (easiest would probably still just be a traditional small mic+tap on the touch and screen interface. Or room/car surveillance...).
Signal might be adequately secure to thwart no-cost/zero-per-user investment, drag-net surveillance, and at the same time not secure enough to avoid targeted surveillance.
That's a serious accusation to make. Back it up or take it back.
It's not an accusation, it's a comment on a forum. It is a popular opinion, and there is a vast precedent for it
What's that, you say? A bunch of randos on the Internet believe something? I hadn't considered that.
I wonder if they might also have useful alternative perspectives on the deformation of steel under shear load and heat stress, or on the suitability of different casual Italian restaurants for child sex abuse.