News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by sctb on Monday May 01, 2017 @02:35PM (#14240198)
We detached this flagged subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14234881.
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by partiallypro on Sunday April 30, 2017 @10:24PM (#14235185)
The Nation is not exactly a great source to use on this particular topic. It also has virtually nothing to do with the "alt-right" I know a lot of moderate people that stopped watching ESPN simply because sports is an escape and ESPN has attempted to make it not one. I guess "the alt-right" is now what the left is using on everyone on the right because people associate it with racism. To be fair, the alt-right is entrenched in racism...but that's not the National Review, nor is it conservatism or libertarianism. It's like when people on the "right" call everyone on the left a Communist. Not even remotely true, though some are. Blanket statements and broad categorization of political views is not good for political discourse, it's actually part of the problem, imo.
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by hackuser on Monday May 01, 2017 @02:18AM (#14235902)
> The Nation is not exactly a great source to use on this particular topic

Agreed, they have a clear bias.

> I know a lot of moderate people that stopped watching ESPN

How many? 10? A statistically significant number?

Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by partiallypro on Monday May 01, 2017 @11:51AM (#14238555)
I grant you it's an anecdote, but I think there are poll numbers to support that people tend to shy away from sports broadcasts that are more political. I believe they did polling on Colin Kaepernick and his effect on NFL ratings. I can't find a direct ESPN study, but I can link you to tons of articles of them being political and generally left leaning.
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by hackuser on Monday May 01, 2017 @02:41PM (#14240252)
> I can link you to tons of articles of them being political and generally left leaning

Isn't that falling into the trap of repetition = truth? People repeat falsehood and rumors as much as the truth, and they rarely check the facts. Humans are hardwired to follow social norms not verify facts - e.g., the scientific method didn't arise for thousands of years, and takes great discipline - if everyone is repeating something, that becomes the norm. Propaganda campaigns, some that lead people to far more awful things than criticizing ESPN, rely on it.

I can find a ton of articles and far more online posts saying that the science of climate change is inconclusive, but that's not true. (And a related point: For thousands of years humanity had misconceptions about nature; everyone repeated them; but they weren't true.)

That's why I'm interested in a factual basis, but not in what people repeat. If they are repeating something factual, then there will be a basis for it.

> I think there are poll numbers to support that people tend to shy away from sports broadcasts that are more political

That would be valuable. But I'd like to see it (and it depends on the definition of political).

Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by partiallypro on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @11:17AM (#14247052)
No, I mean I can link you to ESPN published articles that are overtly political. I don't mean to say that I can link you to a blog article claiming it's political.
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by wtf_is_up on Sunday April 30, 2017 @10:19PM (#14235150)
Would you consider Linda Cohn, who has anchored more SportsCenter editions than anybody in ESPN history [1], an "unserious" person?

[1]: http://www.sportingnews.com/other-sports/news/linda-cohn-spo...

Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by twoodfin on Monday May 01, 2017 @07:34AM (#14236825)
For the record, the correct ideological slur for the National Review is "neocon", not "alt-right".
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by strictnein on Monday May 01, 2017 @01:15AM (#14235723)
What a ridiculous quote. I like how if you think that ESPN has become politicized you're a racist and a misogynist. And likely a member of the alt-right, I guess. Not surprising from The Nation of course, which is for the feeble minded.

ESPN stated they're becoming more political. That they're going to focus more on how culture and politics intersects with sports.

Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by redthrowaway on Sunday April 30, 2017 @10:17PM (#14235138)
>This sends the alt-right sewers of the Internet and their minions at publications like the National Review into fits of hysterics.

Calling the National Review alt-right is an affront to the English language.

Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by partiallypro on Sunday April 30, 2017 @10:26PM (#14235193)
The National Review made a famous issue "Against Trump" and constantly has editors slamming Trump and "the new right." The "new right" is actually the "alt-right." Trump himself openly attacked the editors and everyone that is Alt-Right essentially despises the publication. The Nation doesn't even pretend to approach things objectively.
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by NoGravitas on Monday May 01, 2017 @08:46AM (#14237083)
Agreed; as someone posted above, the correct ideological slur for the National Review is "neocon".
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by redthrowaway on Monday May 01, 2017 @04:30PM (#14241246)
And I doubt anyone at the National Review would consider that a slur.
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by cardiffspaceman on Sunday April 30, 2017 @10:24PM (#14235183)
Well to be precise the National Review is referred to as a minion of the alt-right. Also it's a quote from the Nation so, as a liberal I think they shouldn't have wasted the keystrokes.
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by judah on Monday May 01, 2017 @10:14AM (#14237567)
No. You are mistaken.

The National Review is a vociferous opponent of the alt-right, and has been since the beginning of that movement. The National Review is American conservative small government. The alt-right is European-style nationalist big government.

The National Review has opposed President Trump from the beginning for this reason. Its editors, perhaps most notably Bill Kristol [0], has been a leading voice for the Never Trump conservative movement.

[0]: http://www.nationalreview.com/author/william-kristol

Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by pcardh0 on Sunday April 30, 2017 @09:57PM (#14235032)
The National Review is not alt-right. Don't believe me, read it and decide where it fits on the spectrum of things.
[dead]
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by sctb on Monday May 01, 2017 @03:50PM (#14240873)
No matter what we're replying to, the guidelines ask that we don't do this:

> Please avoid introducing classic flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say about them.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[dead]
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by sctb on Monday May 01, 2017 @08:42PM (#14243104)
Users flagged the comment because it violates the guidelines, which is how this site works. The way to avoid this is to not violate the guidelines, which in this case would mean increasing the information-to-inflammation ratio in your comment significantly. This is asked of every commenter, no matter what opinion they're expressing or "side" they're on.
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by tptacek on Monday May 01, 2017 @10:41AM (#14237791)
There is literally never a thread on HN where comments like these --- or whatever their left-leaning equivalent might be --- are appropriate. This isn't discussion, it's vandalism.
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by wtf_is_up on Sunday April 30, 2017 @10:14PM (#14235124)
Alt-right has become a catch-all boogeyman for anyone who doesn't identify as a """progressive""".
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by NoGravitas on Monday May 01, 2017 @08:45AM (#14237073)
Would you prefer vice signaling?
Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by hackuser on Monday May 01, 2017 @02:24AM (#14235922)
> bias against white males?

IME, the premise that such a thing exists (with any meaningful impact at any meaningful scale) almost defines the white nationalists (alt-right). The racists with some intelligence rarely will outright say something socially unpopular; they try to make themselves palatable - 'we don't hate people based on their skin color, we just want to protect people like you with white skin from the victimization we are facing'. It's an old tactic: Adolph invaded other countries to protect Germans; Russia recently invaded Ukraine to protect Russians; everyone is a victim.

Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by kr7 on Monday May 01, 2017 @04:30AM (#14236264)
You do realize that is exactly why alt-righters believe there is bias against white people?

"We need to protect minorities and women from the white male oppressors" is basically the slogan of the identity politics wing of the left.

Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by hackuser on Monday May 01, 2017 @04:46AM (#14236316)
> "We need to protect minorities and women from the white male oppressors" is basically the slogan of the identity politics wing of the left.

No, that's something white nationalists say to each other; I don't see it elsewhere (in any significant quantity). There is overwhelming evidence of discrimination against people who are in minorities and against women, and as these people are largely excluded from power due to that same discrimination, they have little ability to protect themselves. If we believe in liberty, opportunity and meritocracy, and basic morality for everyone, then everyone should do something about it.

For the most part, only white nationalists say white-skinned people are discriminated against (with any significant scale or impact). There is no evidence of it that I've seen and a look around SV and the IT industry, corporate offices, governments and legislatures of every Western nation, college campuses, and any other locale of wealth, power and privilege shows how absurd the idea is. But the argument is not about discrimination, it's propaganda that is about creating hatred, trying to get people to see everyone as friends or enemies based on skin color (which is perhaps why white nationalists think there's some sort of bizarre us vs. them team competition), and providing a (transparent) excuse for racial hatred. Few people are fooled.

Re:ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This by kr7 on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @08:09PM (#14251950)
You say "we need to protect minorities and women from the white male oppressors" is not an accurate representation of their viewpoint.

Then you proceed to say that minorities and women are discriminated against, and we need to do something about that. Who is doing this discrimination, then? You point out that white-skinned people tend to hold power in (traditionally white) Western nations. I would say that my description is accurate.