You can disagree all you want but I'll go with the judge who got all the facts.
Let's remember that he had problems with other people inside the team, not only with the PI.
Note that the judge specifically said this:
"It does not appear to be disputed that at all relevant times the lab members were approximately 35 in number. Defendants submitted affidavits from five of those 35, two of whom included Muela and Grass, one of the three alleged to have knowingly participated with Rubin in the alleged scientific misconduct and her boyfriend. Plaintiff has submitted other affidavits and emails based on personal knowledge of others, all of which support that plaintiff then had no mental health issues or concerns."
So out of 35 people in the lab, only five submitted affidavits, and three of those were connected to the original complaint. German submitted (an unknown number of) affidavits and emails in support of his position.
That kind of people hurts the workplace and brings the all team down.
> "Plaintiff has submitted other affidavits and emails based on personal knowledge of others, all of which support that plaintiff then had no mental health issues or concerns"
This immediately followed the line:
> "Defendants submitted affidavits from five of those 35, two of whom included Muela and Grass, one of the three alleged to have knowingly participated with Rubin in the alleged scientific misconduct and her boyfriend."
Which, to me, suggests that the first 5 affidavits did allege that he had "mental health issues or concerns".
Three of those five can be dismissed:
> The "fear" that three of the lab members expressed concerning German appears, at least to this court, exaggerated.
The other two could be explained as "Rubin's retaliation was getting to German, and two people were worried enough about German that they wrote 'he might have a mental health issue or concern' in an affidavit" - although multiple others were willing to say, either in affidavits or emails, "he's fine".
The other two could also be explained as "Rubin wrote an affidavit for them to sign, and stood there until they signed it" - given that Rubin was found to have retaliated against German, would it be within his character to similarly terrorize other lab members? I don't know, and I don't need to know - the judge's finding seems to me to strongly suggest that the only reason German's mental health was brought into question was because Rubin intentionally raised it.
Plus, if you're willing to say "pissing off 5 out of 35 makes him an asshole", would you say the same about "pissing off 2 out of 35"? Or what about "worrying 2 out of 35", since we don't know what their affidavits actually said?
* People should regain authority - check.
* Political correctness makes the problem worse - check.
* More competition would solve the problem - check.
Someone should make a bingo game for comments like this.
From the judge's opinion:
"I accept that at least Rubin, as PI for plaintiff and a number of grad students and because he is head of the Rubin Lab, brings in a lot of funding and has a lot of authority at Harvard. So much authority that Cardozo would likely be deferential and not interfere with Rubin's choice to dismiss a grad student."
This German guy didn't suffer any kind of racial or gender based discrimination by the PI, he just proved over more than one year that he was not the kind of person that could work in a team and the PI used what he could (although wrongly in the execution, cause sending someone to German's house in the middle of the night was wrong) to get rid of the guy.
If the PI had more authority (and he obviously should have and now we wouldn't have this issue) he should have just told the guy to pack his things and leave since he was hurting the team and the research being carried out.
Presumably you are saying this conditional upon the accusations of academic fraud being false? If the research was indeed being faked, I feel like the controversy is preferable to allowing such practices to continue. Or do you think that quietly removing German would have been a better outcome regardless?
What I find hard to believe is that, after all the issues that German had with the team before coming up with those accusations, those accusations are actually true. Specially given the exact accusation, which is quite odd, German claims that some (not all) points are false about experiments where he wasn't directly involved.
Still, in any case, even without the issue of academic fraud and/or it's accusation existing, the previous behavior from German is not that of someone I would like to have my team as a colleague, much less if I was the PI. I never in my life had anything that amounted to this kind of trouble with any member of my team at work... much less with 5 of them. SO, on that light, I think there is a problem when the PI doesn't have enough authority to remove someone like German.
If the personality conflicts arose before the accusation of fraud, I'd agree with you, but it's not clear that this was the order of events. The judge's description suggests that the conflicts arose after the report of fraud, with the implication that despite anonymity the accused (who were the ones with whom there was conflict) immediately concluded that German was the source of the accusation.
So for me, it all depends on whether the accusations of academic fraud of justified. If the accusations are true and substantial, German is probably the aggrieved party, or at least deserving of sympathy. If they are not, he is poisonous to the the lab and should be cast out. Without knowing the details of the complaint, I don't feel I have any way of knowing the probabilities of the different possibilities.
Circumstantially, I was impressed though by the rationality and civility of German's communications that were cited in the judge's ruling[1]. His email to an undergraduate advisee explaining that he was unable to continue his labwork seemed like a model of tact and good communication:
"Hi Alex, unfortunately, due to personal matters I'm off from school. I don't know when I'm coming back. Meanwhile, you have to find another mentor. I highly recommend you to contact Becca (Rebecca Gibbs) for a mentor since she is a very bright scientist (mentored by me) and she was interested in having an undergraduate. This is the most I can do for you at the moment. I'm very sorry about this. My best, Gustavo."
That this was the letter used to justify the attempt to have German involuntarily committed for his own safety (emphasizing "I don't know when I'm coming back") makes me doubt the doubt the "good will" of the advisor. The judge shared this doubt, although it's entirely possible there is further background not brought up in the trial that would justify the advisor's concern.
[1] https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:86cjl1...