Also new accounts have severe restrictions on number of comments per day. Maybe he's trying to bypass that.
Practically no one on this site is shadowbanned anymore (as far as I know it only happens to spammers and the like). If you piss off the new mods ("new" as of several years ago), they'll publicly announce your banning; there's effectively a modlog on the site now in the comment histories of 'dang and 'sctb. That's a deliberate choice. What Paul Graham (and his original, part-time moderation team) were doing was ineffective, because stealth bans are simultaneously provocative and have no power to reinforce norms among the rest of commenters.
Plenty of people have been banned on HN and gone on to make some sockpuppet or another, and so long as those sockpuppets don't do the same things that got their original accounts banned, they survive on HN. If you read between the lines on Dan and Scott's comments, this seems to be informally condoned. Nobody's looking for a giant fight here. Moderation is a means to an end, not an end in itself.
Long story short: by all means use throwaways to prosecute arguments you don't want your identity attached to†. But making a new throwaway mid-thread is obnoxious and sort of intrinsically uncivil. I won't have a conversation with someone who does that. What I'll do instead is flag the comments.
† I'd personally rather you didn't, and never do myself, but I'll check my privilege, if wishes were fishes, &c.
What I'm saying is: maybe that's his case and dismissing his arguments because he can't use a normal account is silly.
Here's where I draw the line. Sorry if that bothers you, but if it does, you're wrong, not me. Nobody needs to earn their boundaries and nobody is entitled to a response from anyone else here. But even if that wasn't the case, I'd've more than earned my boundaries a long time ago.
[On mobile] when I write a comment it's already dead automatically on page refresh.
Have you contacted the mods to see why these might be the case? If you're using HN relatively often, I suggest joining the community by using a persistent username.
I'm not interested in talking to him about it and I'll keep posting anyway. People almost never care about my account being new when I comment at all so this works for me. Thanks for your suggestion though.