News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by sctb on Monday October 24, 2016 @02:09PM (#12781245)
We detached this flagged subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12778761 and marked it off-topic.
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by maxerickson on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:22AM (#12779008)
It's not "the right" and "the left" that commit acts of violence and steal signs, it's small groups of people.
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by rybosome on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:15AM (#12778931)
How about the violence at Trump rallies towards protesters and journalists? Or the case of Trump supporters beating a homeless Hispanic man, about which Trump noted "my supporters are very passionate"?

Let's not pretend that there hasn't been violence associated with Trump's campaign.

Edit: responding to the claim that there has been nothing on the right compared to the left. Not trying to excuse the behavior of the left by arguing who is worse.

Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by Alex3917 on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:17AM (#12778960)
> How about the violence at Trump rallies towards protesters and journalists?

The point of the grandparent comment was that these cases were (presumably) mentally ill homeless people who Hillary's campaign paid to beat up minorities on camera.

Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by leesalminen on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:23AM (#12779021)
Even if they weren't paid, they were still likely mentally ill. IMO, that speaks more about access to mental health services than a particular candidate.
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by Alex3917 on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:27AM (#12779061)
Well we know for a fact that they were paid, because they recorded the payments in the FEC filings to get the tax write off. What exactly they were paid for is more open to interpretation. We know for a fact that they were paid to go to the rallies to try to create violence, and it's strongly implied that they were supposed to start beating up minorities themselves if they couldn't provoke actual Trump supporters into doing it, but it's not explicitly stated.
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by leesalminen on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:17AM (#12778959)
Isn't it possible this is all bought and paid for by the opposing party. You shouldn't believe everything you see on TV.
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by rybosome on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:21AM (#12778989)
Sure, it is possible. Isn't it also possible that people who hear a powerful man blaming protesters, the press and immigrants for their troubles would get angry and lash out at them?
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by jsmthrowaway on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:19AM (#12778974)
Except when it supports a particular narrative, right?
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by artursapek on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:24AM (#12779030)
The entire point of the paid-for violence uncovered by Project Veritas was to paint Trump supporters as the violent ones. So yeah, there's reason to question whether those were actual Trump supporters (who from my experience are generally very peaceful).
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by leesalminen on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:24AM (#12779033)
No, not right.
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by leesalminen on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:13AM (#12778918)
Agreed. I'm not a Trump "supporter", but I am also not easily swayed by what the media has to say.

Whenever I attempt to clarify my understanding of what he's said with what the media said he said I'm shot down, laughed at or receive weird looks. People want to believe the news.

Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by jsmthrowaway on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:12AM (#12778906)
It's very easy to blame the other side for things when it fits a narrative, but your second example link is most notably missing a shred of evidence that "the left" (what does that even mean? Lumping in Communists and the Green Party, too?) is responsible. I agree with you that behaviors in this election have been concerning, but taking a victim stance and just blindly pointing at a side is probably most concerning of all because it isn't really refutable despite your edit.
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by artursapek on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:13AM (#12778923)
Oh come on. Did you see the graffiti addressing the "Nazi Republicans"? That was clearly a partisan act.
Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by jsmthrowaway on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:16AM (#12778945)
Based on what? That someone who doesn't like Republicans must be from the "other team" without any other possibility remotely existing?

How about instead of asking us to refute you, please prove your accusation against "the left," specifically for the North Carolina example that you feel is clear. I'm eager to hear your evidence that an entire side of the political spectrum was responsible for the act.

Oh, come on, indeed.

Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by artursapek on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:27AM (#12779059)
After seeing what Project Veritas has revealed, it's abundantly clear that the left is perfectly okay with using this kind of domestic terrorism as a tactic against their opponents. So while there's no hard evidence in the North Carolina case, I think it's a safe assumption. They've earned that reputation.

Like it or not, this is pretty much a game between two teams. Independents have no reason to lash out like that. I wish we had more than two major parties - I really do.

Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by jsmthrowaway on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:29AM (#12779076)
Put another way, you have absolutely no evidence a particular team you dislike was responsible for a specific event, but you're more than willing to blame them publicly for it based on something totally unrelated and even more flimsy because a reputation has developed in your mind (and the minds of those like you), and you're willing to surrender all logic to arrive at your position. Then, ironically, you talk about partisanship while missing how partisan your own remarks are.

It's disgusting to watch people attack "the left" and "the right" as a boogeyman. It's "you're not on my team, so you're part of a grand conspiracy to take down my team," which is a line of thinking that has never, ever been dangerous in American history.

I'm from "the left" and I find your examples abhorrent. What does that make me? Did I miss the meetings where we gang up on the poor folks from "the right?"

Please prove your accusation regarding, specifically, "the left." I'm still waiting. One question I have is how all the parties on "the left" coordinate. Do we all have dirty tricks operatives who meet between all the parties over here? Or is this a unilateral Democrat conspiracy?

Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by artursapek on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:39AM (#12779166)
You're right - I was wrong to blame that particular event on "the left". I lumped it together in the same sentence with another event that can be blamed on them with hard evidence. I'll admit that I was wrong to lump them together like that.

However, this is really beside the point. My original comment was simply trying to explain why Trump supporters are shy to show their political stance. The violence against the headquarters in North Carolina is still a completely valid reason for that - a building got firebombed because it was used by people with a particular political stance. So it doesn't really matter whether it was committed by liberals or some other group I'm not aware of, and I didn't mean to make that accusation the focus of my comment (though you latched on to it nonetheless).

Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by jsmthrowaway on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:43AM (#12779205)
No, your not-so-subtle accusation that "the left" was responsible for burning down that building is the whole point because you are galvanizing your side based on a fear-based rhetoric and a complete disregard of facts. You're now trying a different tack several replies into this thread because you've realized I am correct; your apology and reversal is very hollow given that mere minutes ago you were advising me to "oh come on" and just admit that the event is clearly partisan.

I "latched on" to this particular claim because your own citation comes with absolutely no proof that "the left" was responsible and it is trivial to demonstrate the tactic that you are employing. Which you at least admit, to your credit. The point is that many groups in history have played the for us/against us cards much like you're doing here, and the results have never been positive.

I also find it infinitely fascinating that you've assumed a group is responsible for the event, even in this last comment. One crazy person is not an effective narrative to leverage, and groups were initially blamed for Oklahoma City, too, if I recall.

Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by artursapek on Monday October 24, 2016 @10:50AM (#12779292)
> fear-based rhetoric

A place was firebombed because it belonged to republicans, that's terrorism. People are completely right to be afraid to express their opinions because of that. It's not fear-based rhetoric.

Furthermore, there has been no terrorism of this type against liberals.

I just told you that you're right that I should not have made the accusation so casually with no evidence. But as I just wrote, you're missing the point I was trying to make. You've picked out one dubious claim I made and ignored everything else I was trying to say.

Re:Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory by jjawssd on Monday October 24, 2016 @11:06AM (#12779447)
"a complete disregard of facts" ERROR: false premise