News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Link between police shootings and voter registration by sanderjd on Thursday September 29, 2016 @12:11PM (#12606402)
> Violence needs to--has to--be met with equal or greater force to show the thugs who is boss--in this case the legally-appointed police and justice system.

This is a flawed and historically ignorant premise, presented with no justification.

[dead]
Re:Link between police shootings and voter registration by sanderjd on Thursday September 29, 2016 @12:57PM (#12606844)
No, what I mean is that when you say violence "needs to" and "has to" be met with equal or greater violence, you are just incorrect, from a historical standpoint. One of the great innovations of civilization was non-violent responses to violence, which usually prove to be more effective and lasting solutions.

I think what you mean is that, in your opinion, violence should be met with equal or greater violence, for the reasons you've given. I don't agree with you, but you're entitled to that opinion. But it just isn't accurate to say that it needs to be handled in the way you think it should be.

Re:Link between police shootings and voter registration by dragonwriter on Thursday September 29, 2016 @12:42PM (#12606700)
> Violence needs to--has to--be met with equal or greater force to show the thugs who is boss

There may be some truth to that (or at least the weaker position that proportionate violence is necessary for this purpose), but even if this is necessary as a response, it is manifestly not sufficient as a preventive measure. Moreover, it is pretty much absolutely guaranteed to make the problem worse if the violence on the part of the "legitimate" authorities is not exquisitely carefully directed at the appropriate targets, because when violence that may be justified when used against "thugs" is misdirected at people (and those who such people care about) who are not already, but are at risk of being, alienated from the system, it often effects their alienation. [0]

And this is how legitimacy of the authorities -- which is almost precisely the extent to which people are not alienated from the system -- breaks down.

[0] In fact, this is also a problem with disproportionate violence of the type you recommend even when appropriately directed, which is one of the reasons that the argument that disproportionate violence for exemplary purposes is necessary (even if not sufficient) is dubious.

Re:Link between police shootings and voter registration by tdb7893 on Thursday September 29, 2016 @11:07AM (#12605836)
I understand where you are coming from and I think the disagreements come from underlying philosophical differences and differences in experiences that I don't have time to debate before going to work. Thank you for exposing me to a different viewpoint and staying polite in the discussion.