News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Never trust a programmer who says he knows C++ by chancho on Monday March 29, 2010 @09:57PM (#1228114)
> Anybody who says they are good at C++ is either delusional or has spent years writing, linking, debugging it.

This strikes me as a completely reasonable and not deprecating thing to say about any powerful language (such as C) or any advanced tool in any profession for that matter.

Re:Never trust a programmer who says he knows C++ by pmiller2 on Monday March 29, 2010 @11:49PM (#1228303)
I'll speak about my two main sharp instruments these days: C and Python. IMO, it doesn't take years to get "good" at these languages (C, because it's a smallish language; Python because it tends to obey the principle of least surprise fairly often). With sufficiently deliberate study, I think it'd be fair to call oneself "good" at either C or Python after a single year.

I suppose I probably ought to clarify what I mean by that. I mean that someone "good" at C or Python is someone who's made it over all of the typical newbie hurdles and is able to spot typical newbie mistakes more or less at a glance. This is not someone I'd expect to have total control or mastery over the language or to know the respective standard libraries inside and out.

Now, to become an expert in either of them, then, sure, you're going to need many years of experience (and, if you want to claim to be a Python expert, you need to be at least "good" at C, IMO, because there are times when you're just going to need to suck it up and write a C extension).

Re:Never trust a programmer who says he knows C++ by tman on Monday March 29, 2010 @10:09PM (#1228138)
Badly standardized? Not since the mid-90's. And the days of cross-compiler pain went away almost completely when the last big holdout of the pre-standard days, Microsoft, finally released their 2003 C++ compiler.

Your next point, that C++ is just C "with OO" strikes me as deeply ignorant. OO is an important feature, but 95% of the language innovation of the last 20 years has been in templates.

Compilation errors are a pain in C++. It's something that takes months for a smart programmer to figure out. Debugging C++ is harder than debugging C, yes. It's a more complex beast.

Reading your post I get the impression of someone who has read a lot more about C++ than working with C++. Try interacting with any modern C++ code-base (something written in the last 10 years), avoiding the template meta-programming code-bases which are really only of use for library-writers not library-users.

Re:Never trust a programmer who says he knows C++ by joe_the_user on Monday March 29, 2010 @11:34PM (#1228271)
Hey, I'm programming in C++ right now. It's the worst language there is except for the all others (to paraphrase Churchill on democracy). I'm glad to see someone can say something good about it.

I'd also rather be programming in c++ than rating myself in c++ or any other language. The whole experience of being asked to pick a number for your skill level is truly annoying.