News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by jacquesm on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @09:56AM (#11993795)
> Can we just line them all up against the wall?

No.

I am assuming you meant this as a figure of speech, but it is a very unfortunate one.

As for your edit:

I am assuming that the downvotes are because you express yourself in a way that doesn't help at all. The statistic being what they are you are either unware of the statistical insignificance of that number or you are but you are inflating it to make it seem more important than it really is.

Yes, statistically speaking there may be 59 'premature deaths', but that does not quantify just how premature those deaths were, nor does it acknowledge that transportation carries an enormous cost in lives over and beyond that tiny little bit extra because of these emissions.

Yes, VW did a really bad thing, yes, they should be punished. But the cost of transportation already being what it is the punishment seems to be roughly in line with the extent of the crime.

If you're really concerned about this you should campaign for us all to stop driving, that will really move the needle.

Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by SwellJoe on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @01:57PM (#11995934)
"If you're really concerned about this you should campaign for us all to stop driving, that will really move the needle."

I do that, too, to the best of my ability. And, whenever given the chance I argue for self-driving cars, too. Yes, the entire auto industry (and our addiction to it as a society) is terrible.

But, my point is that even the mild environmental and health regulations we have were defeated for years for VW profits, all while they advertised "clean diesel" and went head to head in the market with technologies that are actually superior and safer (unless those companies are cheating, too), claiming to be better than them by using falsified data.

My point is really that when a company in an industry that already kills on an unprecedented scale decides to willfully harm even more because they'll profit, there should be truly dire consequences. BP is another great example of a company that consistently made decisions that knowingly endangered entire communities over a long period of time. Their only regret seems to be getting caught.

Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by jacquesm on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @02:46PM (#11996375)
Transportation is a fact of life, no amount of wishing is going to make it go away and you'd not be able to make a world without it work at the level that we're at currently. Of course we can do better, but that's likely going to be marginal rather than some kind of revolutionary change.

VW messed up, sure. I've been pretty explicit about my criticism of what they've done, and I would happily see Winterkorn serve jailtime (fat chance of that ever happening).

But I think you are magnifying the damage done way out of proportion.

FWIW, 15B for 59 premature deaths is a very large premium compared to what we, the western nations typically think a life in some Oil rich country is worth, and those people too are indirect victims of our transportation.

Proportionality is what it is all about and I really miss that element in your comments here.

Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by moptar on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @08:42AM (#11993263)
The extent to which it cost human lives is a function of the arbitrary emission standards that governments have set. Those standards are obviously chosen as a trade-off between too many harmful consequences of pollution and being too expensive for car makers to comply with. So it's not as clear as "VW killed people" but more like "VW killed more people than we expected them to." The standards themselves still allow some harmful emissions to be released. If had more relaxed standards then all the extra harm caused by the VW cheating would simply evaporate.
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by SwellJoe on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @09:29PM (#11998910)
But, we have the standards we have (which are already weaker than they need to be to avert a climate and air quality disaster going forward). If one company is permitted to fake results, it means all companies will have to fake results to compete.

My argument is that cheating our already lax air quality and environmental standards should be a tremendous deal. It shouldn't be something that can be swept under the rug or written off as a cost of doing business.

Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by rbobby on Monday June 27, 2016 @10:46PM (#11991152)
Under your theory of the crime it was some form of negligent homicide? And you want to hold all the receptionists accountable (lose of job) because they negligently did/failed to do what exactly?
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by SwellJoe on Monday June 27, 2016 @11:16PM (#11991254)
Of course I don't want a receptionist who knew nothing of the crime to lose their job; but, the same scenario can be created for any person who goes to jail. No one wants a baby to grow up without their mother or father, but sometimes people commit crimes, and are punished with jail time, leading to suffering of their whole family. It's not good (and, I think there's a lot to be said for ending our carceral focused criminal justice system), but we as a society do seem to agree that sometimes the good of society as a whole trumps that of an individual or group.

I'm not suggesting that imposing a "death penalty" on a corporation would be a nice thing, or that it would make employees of the corporation happy. I'm not even saying it wouldn't have negative consequences for more than just those directly employed by the company. But, I am saying that when someone commits a truly heinous crime, our society removes them from society by force. Volkswagen has committed a truly heinous crime. If I had my druthers, the CEO and a wide variety of other executives who knew what was going on would be spending their days in a lonely grey room contemplating what they've done. That'd be a good start toward justice.

But, we also have to address the company as a whole. It was not one person who made this decision, and it's probably literally impossible to know who knew and who did what with any precision. Pretty much the entire company is suspect. We can't expect internal processes to correct this kind of malfeasance...they had years to do so, and chose profit over human lives.

Finally: Many corporations have died, through all manner of faults over the years...often, they've failed due to inefficiencies, the Innovator's Dilemma, etc. Very few companies have failed because they killed people. But, it is not the end of the world when a company, even a very large one, dies. It makes room in the market for new competitors. And, in this case, a shake up in the auto industry is a great thing. We need new auto companies that don't willingly trade human and environmental health for greater profits. While VW exists, and wields political power, those new companies (or old companies that want to do right by the world) are competing with a company shown to have no scruples. Ever tried to compete in a business that has high health and safety costs with a competitor that ignores health and safety regulations? That's a part of why Chinese manufacturing destroyed American manufacturing industries.

Someone else mentioned Enron in another comment. I think it's a useful example. The fallout from Enron was hard for a lot of people; and, it was painful across several industries for a little while. But, I believe we're better for killing Enron (and Arthur Andersen). And, I believe the world would be better off, in the long run, by killing VW.

Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by the-dude on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @09:00AM (#11993396)
"Line them all up against the wall?"

Flagged

Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by SwellJoe on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @02:45PM (#11996363)
I'm curious, are you a native English speaker? When you read my comment, do you genuinely believe I'm suggesting killing people (despite my explicitly saying in the previous comment that I oppose the death penalty for people)?

I don't think you're alone in interpreting my comment that way, but I'm not sure I understand why it's been so misinterpreted. I'd like to do better in the future (without giving up entirely on humor, though perhaps I shouldn't quit my day job).

Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by the-dude on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @04:32PM (#11997306)
Your rationale is appreciated but it is about the tone of the discourse. The sentence just makes one think about readers comments on some newspaper sites I guess every country has.
Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by forgetsusername on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @07:50AM (#11992928)
>I'm gonna assume the downvoting is because

You're getting down-voted because you're asking for company executives, who are human beings, to be killed for something that hasn't quite proven out to be a "crime" yet.

Most reasonable people find that repulsive.

While we're at it, why don't we kill everyone who every bought a VW? Surely they are partly culpable.

Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by SwellJoe on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @02:02PM (#11995980)
"You're getting down-voted because you're asking for company executives, who are human beings, to be killed for something that hasn't quite proven out to be a "crime" yet."

Did you really interpret it that way? I'm speaking of companies, not people. Apologies for not being clear. I am speaking of a "corporate death penalty"; one for companies. The person I was replying to said other car companies are doing the same thing, and I would hope they would face consequences as well, if so.

I explicitly stated in my first comment that I oppose the death penalty for humans in criminal cases.

Re:Volkswagen's U.S. diesel emissions settlement to cost $15B by omginternets on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @08:09AM (#11993030)
It's clearly intended as a figure of speech...