News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by yuvadam on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:00PM (#11910862)
> I don't know anything about any of this

> I know nothing so I could be totally out of line here

> I don't want this to come off as like, accepting of rape or violence

Nice case you're making there.

Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by notaharvardmba on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:07PM (#11910896)
Well, I'm pretty clearly not making a case for anything other than my own opinion about the language used. Since I have no emotional attachment to this at all, I'm merely pointing out my initial interpretation, based on the language used, is that this is probably a witch hunt.
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by tn13 on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:32PM (#11911058)
Looks like your original comment was flagged. Unable to see why it was flagged.

Sexual harassment is crime we all must take seriously especially the tech industry which is struggling get in more women.

But at the same time open blogs like these must be taken with a bit of skepticism too because it is one person's story. We must question if not assign malicious motives to the victim.

P.S. What can we do about such cases ?

I think entire tech industry can create a fund specially for victims of sexual abuse so vulnerable women could consult a lawyer for a very low price who will be specialized in handling such cases. The hammer of justice must be brought into picture as soon as possible. It is unfair that some women has to live with this burden for so many years.

Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by sethish on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @03:10PM (#11911323)
Did you miss the link to http://jacobappelbaum.net/ where the rest of the testimonies are collected? Or read any of the other blogposts on the subject like this one? https://blog.patternsinthevoid.net/the-forest-for-the-trees....

It isn't a single 'open blog'. Alison is a widely respected member of the infosec, internet freedom and librarian communities.

Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by notaharvardmba on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @03:48PM (#11911640)
Clearly people are personally upset with my interpretation and are voting me down. But that's the mob mentality at work. Alleged victims now silence THEIR critics, it's a case of black kettle pot things. This is a textbook witchhunt, and now that I've heard from other comments how they don't care for the police either the whole thing just seems like some online teleplay and not "news" at all.

I also feel that it's not that we all need or want more women in tech, it's that we need and want fewer men. It's weird that a good chunk of the women trailblazing back into tech (after all, programming was primarily a women's occupation as late as the 70's) are hyper feminists who maybe want to be programmers but also really want to just do something that most people now perceive as a "male" occupation, for personal or gender pride or whatever. Hear me out, before you flag this one too.

This (programming is a male occupation) is a horrible fallacy that is running through our society, especially in the most common female mindsets. Programming is not a classically male occupation, and programming ability has nothing to do with gender. It's not something where physical strength is valuable and thus statistically more likely that a male is the best candidate available in the labor pool to work it.

And when you think about it, programming is really the perfect job for a woman who also wants to take time off or have flexible hours for having a baby and raising a family (common reasons for the most common choices for female degrees, education and social work). A good chunk of women plan their careers around their desire to have a family, you see. This is out of choice and it's not something where there's a guy in HR who is looking at a file of a man and a file of a woman and giving the man a raise (on average).

I don't know why more women aren't clamoring to get trained and get jobs in programming, but from what I've seen first hand, it's not discrimination by men, or sexual harassment or any of that. I think it's due to other women shaming women programmers for working in a male industry when it's not and being male provides no advantage. It's women on women that's the main problem. I think it's due to women not getting college degrees in the right areas and that's something pretty easy to fix. The industry as it is now is still pretty new and I think that most educated women have set out and dominated the other areas (law, medicine, accounting, business management) and tech just hasn't had the social appeal that strong women want in a career. It's not fun or socially awesome to sit and program all day. Why would you do that to your life when you could be in meetings or selling stuff or curing cancer or fighting a court battle? I think once everyone realizes that programming ability is maybe something socially desirable (who knows if that will ever happen), women will flow back in and probably dominate this world also, just naturally.

So, anyway, I personally don't feel that bad for today's women programmers. It's not men's fault the majority of your peers went into a soft social science, nursing, education or business degree and are now leading fun, awesome lives in really fun, socially important careers. I am sorry that the rest of your gender has let you down and now you are working alone in a really bad line of work that's hard on your body and is mostly dominated by weird shut-ins and people unable to communicate. Teach your daughters to program, teach them that making computers do things is as cool as making a recipe or whatever, and teach their friends also. And I think that this is already happening and in about 10 years the problem will resolve itself. In the meantime, you are going to have an industry dominated by 90% mostly socially awkward men and 10% mostly hyper-fem women and that's just a recipe for all kinds of mudslinging, misunderstandings, sexual misconduct and agenda-beating, and I feel this is yet another case.

Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by jordigh on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:24PM (#11911010)
> get their feelings hurt in non-illegal ways

Since the victims have very little trust[1] in the ability of the judicial system to handle this properly, the question about whether what Jacob did is legal or not is entirely unimportant. What matters is if there are victims who are hurt in more than just "their feelings". Given the number of credible people who have voiced concerns, and given that most of them also think that Jacob should get help, not go to jail, it seems very safe to believe the victims. The alleged damage done to them outweighs the possible damage that Jacob could face for being falsely accused by so many people.

Anyway, it's not like Jacob has any shortage of advocates in the public. He's charismatic, smart, likable. He'll be able to surround himself with supporters far more easily than his vulnerable victims can.

---

[1] Very justifiably, as recent high-profile cases like Brock Turner or Jian Ghomeshi demonstrate.

Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by thegp on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:35PM (#11911082)
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by jordigh on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:45PM (#11911158)
The judge himself acknowledged that the evidence in this case raising a reasonable doubt is not the same as saying these events did not take place. This is where the law fails. Under intense scrutiny and a barrage of questions of details that happened many years ago, anyone can "lie" or have "inconsistencies". A victim can try to befriend the assailant in an attempt to reclaim or recontextualise what happened to her. The law is ill-equipped to handle this situation.
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @03:18PM (#11911392)
> The judge himself acknowledged that the evidence in this case raising a reasonable doubt is not the same as saying these events did not take place.

There is a fairly dramatic, well-known example of this (outside of the area of sexual assault) in the OJ Simpson case where the high (beyond a reasonable doubt) standard of criminal law failed to be met, resulting in a criminal acquittal for murder, but the lower (preponderance of the evidence -- or, in layman's terms, whatever the jury finds is most likely to be true) standard of civil liability resulted in a finding of civil liability for wrongful death.

A criminal acquittal means innocence only from the perspective of the criminal justice system, it doesn't mean the act charged was not committed by the person charged.

Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by thegp on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:51PM (#11911192)
So what should you do? Not apply scrutiny? Remember, in dubio pro reo
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by jordigh on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:58PM (#11911245)
Remember that the verdict of "not guilty" is not the same as "innocent". We can't take away Ghomeshi's freedom, but we can send him to counselling, warn women, or other things that do not require judges and cops.
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by thegp on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @03:09PM (#11911313)
Yes it is kinda."innocent until proven guilty". At least if you believe in rule of law.
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by jordigh on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @07:01PM (#11912762)
In theory, the English legal system is biased towards convicting as few people as possible. The idea with "innocent until guilty" and "beyond a reasonable doubt" is to only convict under the presence of enough undeniable evidence. Because it requires so much to convict, in theory most people will not be convicted. This is because we consider the error of wrongly convicting an innocent person to be far graver than to let guilty people free (the cost of this error is even more dramatic in the case of death penalty).

If you are familiar with hypothesis testing in statistics, it is the exact same idea. Your null hypothesis (innocent) is accepted by default unless you have overwhelming evidence (a very small p-value) that your hypothesis is not true. In that case, you reject the null hypothesis (and convict). But with a lukewarm evidence (not tiny p-value), you just "fail to reject". You never actively accept the null hypothesis.

This is why "not guilty" is not the same thing as "innocent". A court does not attempt to establish someone's innocence or not. A court is biased towards convicting only in the face of undeniable evidence. And that's why things such as whether the victims contacted Ghomeshi after the assault or not are "reasonable doubt" and thus he's acquited. Not because the court proved that the assault didn't happen, but because the court failed to obtain undeniable evidence that it did.

Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by PavlovsCat on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @07:57PM (#11913045)
> Jian Ghomeshi

If you have 40 minutes to spare, I'd be interested to know if there are any remainings criticism of that case other than those that get demolished here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aRyt5FhrBEk

Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by jubalfh on Thursday June 16, 2016 @04:23AM (#11914758)
Oh dear. Who comes next, Elam?
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by PavlovsCat on Thursday June 16, 2016 @01:40PM (#11917645)
Can you elaborate?
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by jubalfh on Thursday June 16, 2016 @03:37PM (#11918335)
Paul Elam.
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by PavlovsCat on Monday June 20, 2016 @09:08PM (#11942835)
And? Use your words.
Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by bsder on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @03:12PM (#11911336)
> Since the victims have very little trust[1] in the ability of the judicial system to handle this properly

So, unsubstantiated character assassination is superior?

It's ironic that you cite the Ghomeshi case which completely fell apart when actually examined by the judicial system.

Re:Alison Macrina: I’m one of the people Jake Appelbaum sexu... by sethish on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:16PM (#11910947)
Tell me, how would you prefer victims to speak?