News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Banned by the Publisher by griffinmb on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @04:50PM (#11076350)
I didn't see it as anti-choice. The explanation and reality-show aspect seemed a little dumb, but I thought the core idea was really intriguing.

I feel like in Sci-Fi, there's often this dynamic between Creator/AI as a Parent/Child relationship, so the idea that a nascent artificial intelligence would perceive abortion as threatening or scary is, in my opinion, a super cool idea.

I didn't read his book, so maybe it really was just anti-choice drek. But from only reading his blog post, it sounds to me like a nugget of an interesting idea with not-as-interesting execution.

Re:Banned by the Publisher by tedks on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:35PM (#11076705)
It's anti-choice drek because it implicitly assumes personhood of a fetus, and in fact, starts an inter-species war over the assumption of personhood of a fetus.

The correct corollary between a fetus would be the uncompiled source code of an AI, or possibly an unexecuted binary. Neither are alive and certainly neither are conscious.

An AI literally exterminating humanity because "abortion is murder" is clearly self-insertion on the part of the author in a way that civil society should not tolerate any more than an AI being a white nationalist.

Re:Banned by the Publisher by griffinmb on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:34PM (#11077099)
Looking at this article more, it does seem more likely that this is an attempt at some weird anti-abortion propaganda.

That being said, I still think it's an interesting concept. I don't think that the AI assuming personhood of a fetus is inherently wrong. There are plenty of philosophical arguments about what constitutes personhood, and how that effects the topic of abortion.

Again, this is something that I think could be potentially very interesting in relation to artificial intelligence, which has it's own fair share of 'what makes it a person' type debate.

An Artificial Intelligence (potentially non-person) relating and empathizing with a fetus (also potentially non-person) -- that's an interesting thought.

I agree though, it does appear to be self-insertion on the part of the author. And, if it matters, I am pro-choice. I just think there is a lot of interesting stuff to be said on the topic of personhood.

Re:Banned by the Publisher by Zikes on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:43PM (#11076763)
You do realize that the AI represents the villain in this story, right? Villains aren't exactly known for being reasonable, civil, or even rational.
Re:Banned by the Publisher by tedks on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:54PM (#11076845)
But a reasonable, empathetic villain:

>I wanted the readers to empathize, as best they could, with our future Robot overlords

So yes, this is intended to be something the reader identifies with.

Re:Banned by the Publisher by ricketycricket on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:02PM (#11076436)
You are making assumptions about the intent of the author you have no ability to make. To be so reductionist as to refer to the author as merely a misogynist "white man" is bigotry and your comment adds nothing to the conversation. In fact, if anything, your reaction proves his point.
Re:Banned by the Publisher by tyingq on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @04:50PM (#11076349)
Not trying to be snarky, honestly. But, this is fiction. Wouldn't you expect a fair amount of viewpoints you didn't agree with to be in a work of fiction? Even outrageous viewpoints?

I do agree that publishers have the latitude to decide what they publish, but it seems odd to complain about fictional viewpoints.

Re:Banned by the Publisher by Zikes on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @04:55PM (#11076376)
> Now if you’re thinking my novel is about the Pro Choice/ Pro Life debate, hold your horses. It’s not. I merely needed a reason, a one chapter reason, to justify the things my antagonist is about to do to the world without just making him a one-note 80’s action flick villain as voiced by John Lithgow. I wanted this villain to be Alan Rickman-deep. One chapter. That’s all.

It's not a particularly terrible trope. I mean, the I, Robot movie features an A.I. that [spoiler] tries to enslave (and even kills some of) humanity in order to take "protection" to its furthest logical extreme.

Politically-motivated characters aren't always representative of the author's political views, and even if they are then you have the simple option of not reading it.

Re:Banned by the Publisher by tedks on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:32PM (#11076681)
The title of the linked post literally says "Conservative author banned".

It is totally fair to infer that the book is a representation of the author's abhorrent political views.