News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:René Girard has died by gbog on Thursday November 05, 2015 @04:32AM (#10512442)
Agree with you. Girard is anti-scientific. It is the typical kind of guy who finds a pseudo-key (mimetics) and applies it to everything and everyone. And if you ever dare to disagree you are also doing that because of mimetism. His theory is simplistic, not very novel, and cannot explain everything.

One very big "hole" in his thinking is that for him no civilization can be accomplished without the Christ and its revelation. So, well, all those incredibly advanced East Asian civilisations? Thrown overboard! Never existed!

Really solid thinkers like Paul Ricœur are a dozen levels higher and deeper than Girard.

And, as HN is not a necrology website, I think it is a very good occasion to criticize a guy's theory the day his death is announced, why not?

Re:René Girard has died by bambax on Thursday November 05, 2015 @04:42AM (#10512480)
Thanks for your support, I seem to really need it!! ;-)

Completely agree with your observation that it's ludicrous to argue that Christianity is consubstantial with human civilization; what about ancient Greece, for starters...?!?

Some very original and deep thought about Christianity, as well as what it means to be "modern", can be found in another French author, Jacques Ellul, who like Girard is more well known in the US than in France (but didn't achieve rockstar status; he died in 1994).

Re:René Girard has died by coldtea on Thursday November 05, 2015 @06:24AM (#10512753)
>Completely agree with your observation that it's ludicrous to argue that Christianity is consubstantial with human civilization; what about ancient Greece, for starters...?!?

Ancient Greece declined, and Greeks adopted Christianity among the very first -- because it solved many of the moral and social problems that led to the decline of their civilization. They actually had abandoned their old gods for a few centuries already, dwelling in eastern gods, neo-platonism, mysticism etc.

But even more importantly, Girard, whether right or wrong, neither says that "Christianity is consubstantial with human civilization" nor ignores Ancient Greece.

Re:René Girard has died by bambax on Thursday November 05, 2015 @06:38AM (#10512783)
> Ancient Greece declined, and Greeks adopted Christianity among the very first

Not before having invented Western civilization, philosophy, mathematics, literature, etc. Thank God we didn't have to wait for Christ for maths, because we'd still be waiting.

Re:René Girard has died by coldtea on Thursday November 05, 2015 @07:12AM (#10512879)
Yeah, we just had to wait on him for that lesser thing, all-encompassing trans-ethnic humane values.

(And before someone shouts "Christianism didn't invent those", citing this or that precedent: sure. Like Apple with the iPod, it just created the first version of them people in large numbers cared about).

Re:René Girard has died by mercurial on Thursday November 05, 2015 @09:23AM (#10513417)
> Yeah, we just had to wait on him for that lesser thing, all-encompassing trans-ethnic humane values.

> (And before someone shouts "Christianism didn't invent those", citing this or that precedent: sure. Like Apple with the iPod, it just created the first version of them people in large numbers cared about).

What about, eg, buddhism? As for trans-ethnic, I thought this was a later addition to Christianity - after all, Jews are still the "chosen people", right?

Re:René Girard has died by keane on Thursday November 05, 2015 @02:13PM (#10515497)
Buddhism is merely a method to accept Nihilism (Nihilism being "the belief that all values are baseless"). The Anathapindika records that the Buddha taught that there was no Creator God (issara-karaṇa-vāda), therefore there were no morals, that the universe was deterministic and there was no free will, but that even so humans should strive to act with loving-kindness ("just because"/Eastern nonrationalism).

Ultimately, the true goal of Buddhism is to achieve "Enlightenment", a state of mind where one fully internalises this Daoist idea that God does not exist and due to this Good and Evil are not different but are one and the same (as depicted in the symbol of the Yin Yang). According to Buddhism, Good and Evil have no real existence, being part of the illusory world of phenomena.

All of the practices done before this (meditation, compassion, tantra, etc) are--as in other branches of Hindu and Dharmic faiths--understood to be merely optional "yogas" or activities to fill the time and enjoy oneself in a Nihilistic world.

Buddhists sometimes claim these practices can lead to Enlightenment, but what they don't mention is any practice on Earth is as likely to lead to this state, because for the Buddhist, wanting Enlightenment is a huge mistake as Moksha/Nirvana/Nihilism is available at all times, without the practices, as our default status. As Jed McKenna notes: Why does Buddhism rarely produce Buddhas? It is because Buddhist practices ("yogas") are not able to transmit the realization that Self is Illusion and All is Nothingness.

Christianity on the other hand teaches that Good and Evil are distinct, objective, and Real, that Good is to be sought and practiced, and that man has been endowed with self-evident, unalienable value having been created in the Image of God, giving unconditional worth to all human persons. As the Personalist Project puts it "those who repudiate God cannot preserve [this affirmation] though they may for a time live by the light of a setting sun".

Re:René Girard has died by coldtea on Thursday November 05, 2015 @05:44PM (#10516665)
>What about, eg, buddhism?

Had some similar ideas, but was mostly concerned with the elimination of the self, which is something different. But more importantly, it was a non-player outside of Asia for the most part of history. Even today, after a century of spreading of Buddhist ideas here, it's cultural impact in the popular culture of West is negligible.

>As for trans-ethnic, I thought this was a later addition to Christianity - after all, Jews are still the "chosen people", right?

Huh? No, jews are not the "chosen people" in Christianity. Christianity has no special affinity to the Jews as such. The tacked-on Old Testament stories relating to Israel etc. -- and previously part of the jewish "state religion" (from the Tower of Babel to Noah's flood etc), are taken to apply to "the whole of humanity" by Christians.

I think it's a shame that in the US especially, most christian doctrine is relegated to the Old Testament -- but then again, the US was founded by christian sectarians thrown out from Europe for such differences of opinion.

Here's how Paul the apostle, put the trans-ethnic thing: "There is no Jew or Greek, slave or free, male or female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus.".

And of course Jesus himself is said to have told his disciples "Go into all the world and preach the gospel to all creation".

Re:René Girard has died by nmrm2 on Thursday November 05, 2015 @07:46PM (#10517188)
> Even today, after a century of spreading of Buddhist ideas here, it's cultural impact in the popular culture of West is negligible.

The reason for the global proliferation of christianity is super duper ironic in light of the central thesis of your post...

Re:René Girard has died by bambax on Thursday November 05, 2015 @07:27AM (#10512911)
Jesus is the iPod of philosophy. Couldn't think of a better definition. Thanks for that.
Re:René Girard has died by coldtea on Thursday November 05, 2015 @09:06AM (#10513324)
No problem. Just don't underestimate the importance of the iPod (or christian ethics -- not just as an inhibitor, as they are now seen, but also as a progressive and important force for centuries).
Re:René Girard has died by charlysisto on Thursday November 05, 2015 @07:49AM (#10512980)
Why anti scientific ? His theory is based on a lot of anthropological observations. He elaborates a very robust hypothesis with rigorous reasoning and comes up with a brilliant/thought-provoking and yet simple theory (so much more simple & elegant than freudian theory) on the structural role of religion, rituals and sacrifice in human societies.

Overall you don't need to agree on everything he says or consider it as scientific ! Scientific proof anyway in human matters are hardly testable, subject to contradiction and ideological bias. So criticizing him because of a lack of scientific rigor is just bashing in an open door.

However I don't know much about Paul Ricoeur, so I'd love to know what you consider great about his work.

Re:René Girard has died by edanm on Thursday November 05, 2015 @03:35AM (#10512272)
I have no thoughts on Rene Girard, having never heard of him before.

Still, just as a matter of civility, perhaps calling him a charlatan and criticizing his work is something that we shouldn't do on a thread announcing his death. There are better places for this.

Re:René Girard has died by bambax on Thursday November 05, 2015 @03:47AM (#10512306)
That's like saying we shouldn't talk about gun control on the day of a mass shooting: when then?

The thread "announcing" his death points to an article comparing him to Voltaire and Racine. Please.

What really upsets me about Girard is his arrogance and how well it worked. It takes some balls to title a book "things hidden since the creation of the world" (meaning, nobody before me was able to think clearly). And it takes some admirable luck to have people fall for it.

Re:René Girard has died by edeion on Thursday November 05, 2015 @04:15AM (#10512387)
You noticed that "things hidden since the creation of the world" is a quote from the Gospel, right? (Matthew, chapter 13, verse 35.) And that Girard's point is to show that the Gospel tries its best to uncover the scapegoating phenomenon?
Re:René Girard has died by bambax on Thursday November 05, 2015 @04:28AM (#10512427)
Sure, here's the full verse: "So was fulfilled what was spoken through the prophet: “I will open my mouth in parables, I will utter things hidden since the creation of the world."

If you use this quote to title your book, how are you not identifying with the "prophet"?

Matthew 13 ends with this: "Coming to his hometown, he began teaching the people in their synagogue, and they were amazed. [...] Where then did this man get all these things? [they asked] And they took offense at him. But Jesus said to them, “A prophet is not without honor except in his own town and in his own home.”

It seems pretty obvious to me, by using this quote taken from this context, that Girard is referencing himself and seeing himself as Jesus, regretting that he's a prophet but in his own country...

Re:René Girard has died by vidarh on Thursday November 05, 2015 @05:28AM (#10512613)
> If you use this quote to title your book, how are you not identifying with the "prophet"?

I have not read the book, so maybe you have an impression based on the contents that justifies this, but standing on its own this statement is entirely ridiculous. How are you identifying with someone just by using a quote as the title of your book?

Re:René Girard has died by coldtea on Thursday November 05, 2015 @06:16AM (#10512736)
>but standing on its own this statement is entirely ridiculous.

Alas, it continues to be ridiculous after one has read the book too.

Re:René Girard has died by edeion on Thursday November 05, 2015 @08:20AM (#10513115)
Somehow, I agree with you on the idea that Girard may consider himself a prophet. But, it must have been depressing for him since (as far as I understood him) he only reframed and repeated what he seemed to read everywhere in literature.

As a layman, I try to sum it up from my memories: according to Girard, desire does not stand by itself. It only rises to meet another's desired object. Somehow: you don't desire a shiny car because of the shine of the car by itself, but only because someone already has or desires a shiny car.

This phenomenon generates conflicts when the desired object can't be shared. This leads to crises in human groups where the only escape was traditionally to take someone (anyone, actually) as culprit for this crisis and kill them, honestly pretending that they are responsible the the group disease.

I don't recall how, but Girard says that this killing cures the group. Which proves to the killers that 1) the scapegoat was indeed responsible for the trouble and 2) it was in the situation of providing the miraculous cure and is therefore some sort of goddess.

This is what Girard explains but refutes to have found by himself. According to him, denouncing this unconscious process is the very purpose of the gospel. This is what has been hidden since the creation of the world.

Re:René Girard has died by lentil_soup on Thursday November 05, 2015 @04:08AM (#10512366)
Huh? Terrible analogy, he didnt die because of his theories or for being a "charlatan"
Re:René Girard has died by bambax on Thursday November 05, 2015 @04:17AM (#10512395)
I'm sorry if this was ambiguous. The analogy isn't about death or how one dies, it's about what's "proper" and what isn't.

People will always try to silence dissenting opinions by arguing it's not the proper time to voice them, that one should wait a while... until we have changed subjects and whatever you had to say can't even be heard anymore, that is.

We shouldn't care about "proper"; the death of an author is an excellent opportunity to discuss his work, for and against, just as the effect of a policy is an excellent time to discuss the policy itself.

Re:René Girard has died by coldtea on Thursday November 05, 2015 @06:15AM (#10512735)
>That's like saying we shouldn't talk about gun control on the day of a mass shooting: when then?

Accusing of "charlatanism" is not merely "talking" or critique. Not to mention the main argument is quoting a "sceptic" webpage, the most cliched and crude approach to break all things non-analytical with a large hammer of scientism and naivety.