News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by seibelj on Friday September 11, 2015 @12:12AM (#10201982)
The comment you responded to was about the utility of quickly filing missing persons reports. Your response said that people with dementia filed as missing would be lucky to survive an encounter with a police officer. It seems like you have an axe to grind that is completely irrelevant to the topic of discussion. I don't know your political inclinations but your arguments are illogical and confusing.

I said it would be better for reddit, because comments like yours are common there, while fairly uncommon on HN

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by DanBC on Friday September 11, 2015 @08:26AM (#10203239)
> Your response said that people with dementia filed as missing would be lucky to survive an encounter with a police officer.

Relatives often call the police when someone with a mental health problem is in distress or has gone for a walk or whatever.

We don't know how many encounters with police end happily. We do know that Many of the encounters that end with a loved one being shot started when a relative called the police.

(Obviously this is in the US. Other countries have plenty of police involvement with mentally ill people, who are sometimes armed with similar weapons to the US cases, that don't end with the ill person being killed.)

I agree with you about how that point is being made.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by MrJagil on Friday September 11, 2015 @07:29AM (#10203072)
I would say that your stab at reddit was just as meaningless as his initial comment. Why didn't you post what you just posted in the first place? If you really want to help keep HN clean, avoid the snide one-liners. Either leave it at a down-vote or post a proper reply.
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by mirimir on Friday September 11, 2015 @12:18AM (#10201997)
You posted an ad hominem attack on police in America. That doesn't even belong on reddit, although it's more common there.

That said, police in America are stuck dealing with the consequences of many short-sighted policy decisions. They are not properly trained for social work, mental health services, and so on.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by ithought on Friday September 11, 2015 @12:59PM (#10204787)
How is that an ad hominem attack?

Most cops aren't properly trained to shoot a gun. Some have 1 training session per year and they have to hit 70% on a target 3 yards away. Most don't seem to know how to react in a confrontation or high-stress situation.

The system is flawed but people have personal responsibility too. You can't absolve someone of criminal acts by saying oh it's someone else's fault.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by rev_bird on Friday September 11, 2015 @09:08AM (#10203429)
> They are not properly trained for social work, mental health services, and so on.

Seems like another one of those short-sighted policy decisions here...

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by morganvachon on Friday September 11, 2015 @06:34PM (#10206507)
Actually many agencies have begun training their officers to properly recognize and approach mentally/emotionally unstable people to offer them assistance, without resorting to use of force. The academy in my area calls it Crisis Intervention Training, and it is a required course for agencies who train at that facility, which is most of northwest Georgia.
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by aquateen on Friday September 11, 2015 @12:49AM (#10202065)
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by bbcbasic on Friday September 11, 2015 @02:55AM (#10202331)
HN Rule 1 - he/she who Latins first ... wins the argument. Game over.
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by mirimir on Friday September 11, 2015 @03:51AM (#10202472)
De gustibus non disputandem ;)

But what about Sanskrit?